LawHealth LawHealth PolicyHealth Care RegulationHealth InsuranceHealth Insurance LawHealth Care SubsidiesHealth Insurance EconomicsHealth Insurance MarketsHealth Insurance RegulationInsurance CoverageHealth Policy LegislationPrivate Health Insurance ProvisionPrivate Health Insurance RegulationPrivate Health Insurance SubsidiesPrivate Insurance CoveragePrivate Insurance PlansPrivate Practice RestrictionsPrivate Sector Regulation
The study examined whether private health care is illegal in Canada. To do so, the authors surveyed health insurance legislation across all 10 provinces. The survey found that regulation primarily seeks to prevent public subsidy of private practice, private insurance for medically necessary services is illegal in six provinces, and the lack of a private sector in the four provinces that allow it is due to prohibitions on public subsidies and restrictions on physicians adding private fees.
We addressed the question of whether private health care is illegal in Canada by surveying the health insurance legislation of all 10 provinces. Our survey revealed multiple layers of regulation that seem to have as their primary objective preventing the public sector from subsidizing the private sector, as opposed to rendering privately funded practice illegal. Private insurance for medically necessary hospital and physician services is illegal in only 6 of the 10 provinces. Nonetheless, a significant private sector has not developed in any of the 4 provinces that do permit private insurance coverage. The absence of a significant private sector is probably best explained by the prohibitions on the subsidy of private practice by public plans, measures that prevent physicians from topping up their public sector incomes with private fees.