The validity of questionnaire measures for assessing depression after stroke

NB Lincoln, Catherine Nicholl, T. Flannaghan, Michael Leonard, Elien Van der Gucht

Clinical Rehabilitation · 2003 · 88 citations · 24 references

Concepts

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: Depression has been reported to occur frequently after stroke. The aim of the study was to assess the validity of questionnaire measures for screening for depression after stroke. DESIGN: Cross-sectional correlational study between questionnaire measures of mood and psychiatric interview. SETTING: Hospital and community. PARTICIPANTS: Stroke patients were recruited from hospital wards and from a randomized controlled trial of cognitive behavioural therapy. MAIN MEASURES: Beck Depression Inventory, Wakefield Depression Inventory, General Health Questionnaire 28 and Schedules for Clinical Assessment in Neuropsychiatry. RESULTS: Poor agreement was found between psychiatric diagnosis and questionnaire measures of mood. The sensitivity of the questionnaire measures was high, but specificity was low. No cut-off points with satisfactory sensitivity and specificity could be identified from ROC curves. CONCLUSIONS: Although questionnaire assessments of depression provide a satisfactory screening method, specificity values are too low to provide a basis for the diagnosis of depression. Measures need to be developed with higher specificity to facilitate screening for depression after stroke.

References

24