Qualitative Inquiry · 1999 · 575 citations · 36 references
Language StudiesLinguisticsDiscourse AnalysisLanguage DocumentationTranscriptionInterpretive MethodologyQualitative Research MethodsEpistemological BeliefsInterview TranscriptsQualitative RigourText TranscriptionTheory-laden ObservationTranscription Standardization
Transcription is a core method in qualitative research across many disciplines, yet its methodological and theoretical issues have received little attention in the literature. The authors aim to review transcription’s role in qualitative inquiry, examining its nature and epistemological assumptions, and argue that its implications for data interpretation and practice decision‑making warrant further study. They conduct a cross‑disciplinary conceptual review of transcription in qualitative inquiry, analyzing its nature and underlying epistemological assumptions. They conclude that transcription is theory‑laden, with researchers’ choices enacting their theories and limiting the interpretations possible from the data.
Transcription is an integral process in the qualitative analysis of language data and is widely employed in basic and applied research across a number of disciplines and in professional practice fields. Yet, methodological and theoretical issues associated with the transcription process have received scant attention in the research literature. In this article, the authors present a cross-disciplinary conceptual review of the place of transcription in qualitative inquiry, in which the nature of transcription and the epistemological assumptions on which it rests are considered. The authors conclude that transcription is theory laden; the choices that researchers make about transcription enact the theories they hold and constrain the interpretations they can draw from their data. Because it has implications for the interpretation of research data and for decision making in practice fields, transcription as a process warrants further investigation.
36
Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook
Journal of Environmental Psychology · 1994 · 45.6K citations
InterViews: An introduction to qualitative research interviewing.
Steinar Kvale · 1996 · 13K citations