Chemical Constraints and Origins of Four Groups of Gulf Coast Reservoir Fluids: DISCUSSION

Lynton S. Land, Dennis R. Prezbindowski

AAPG Bulletin · 1985 · 37 citations · 9 references

Concepts

Abstract

The authors take to task Stoessell and Moore's 1983 review of some previous ideas on the origin of Gulf Coast formation fluids, taking specific exception to their interpretation of data from the Edwards Formation. Six points are emphasized: Edwards brines are significantly enriched in bromide relative to chloride over seawater evaporated to halite saturation; Edwards brines have significantly higher K:C1 and Ca+Mg:C1 ratios than seawater evaporated to halite saturation; Edwards brines cannot achieve molar Ca:Mg ratios of 16 by dolomization; progressive stabilization of metastable dolomite by updip fluid cannot raise the magnesium content of Edwards water in the absence of dolomite dissolution; the volume of brine contained in the Cretaceous section exceeds any reasonable volume of hypothetical connate Mesozoic brine; and, isotopic differences between Edwards brines and Jurassic seawater evaporated to halite saturation are extreme, and therefore preclude recognition of any primary Jurassic component in the current brines.

References

9