Can switching fuels save water? A life cycle quantification of freshwater consumption for Texas coal- and natural gas-fired electricity

Emily Grubert, Fred C. Beach, Michael E. Webber

Environmental Research Letters · 2012 · 99 citations · 11 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Thermal electricity generation is a major consumer of freshwater for cooling, fuel extraction and air
\nemissions controls, but the life cycle water impacts of different fossil fuel cycles are not well understood.
\nMuch of the existing literature relies on decades-old estimates for water intensity, particularly regarding
\nwater consumed for fuel extraction. This work uses contemporary data from specific resource basins and
\npower plants in Texas to evaluate water intensity at three major stages of coal and natural gas fuel cycles:
\nfuel extraction, power plant cooling and power plant emissions controls. In particular, the water intensity
\nof fuel extraction is quantified for Texas lignite, conventional natural gas and 11 unconventional natural
\ngas basins in Texas, including major second-order impacts associated with multi-stage hydraulic
\nfracturing. Despite the rise of this water-intensive natural gas extraction method, natural gas extraction
\nappears to consume less freshwater than coal per unit of energy extracted in Texas because of the high
\nwater intensity of Texas lignite extraction. This work uses new resource basin and power plant level
\nwater intensity data to estimate the potential effects of coal to natural gas fuel switching in Texas’ power
\nsector, a shift under consideration due to potential environmental benefits and very low natural gas
\nprices. Replacing Texas’ coal-fired power plants with natural gas combined cycle plants (NGCCs) would
\nreduce annual freshwater consumption in the state by an estimated 53 billion gallons per year, or 60% of
\nTexas coal power’s water footprint, largely due to the higher efficiency of NGCCs.

References

11