Audit Firm Size and Going-Concern Reporting Accuracy

Marshall A. Geiger, Dasaratha V. Rama

Accounting Horizons · 2006 · 335 citations · 27 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Prior work suggests Big 4 audit firms are higher quality, yet existing tests of audit‑firm size on reporting accuracy are indirect and yield mixed results. This study investigates whether Big 4 firms produce fewer going‑concern reporting errors than non‑Big 4 firms. The authors analyze type I (modified opinions for later viable clients) and type II (unmodified opinions for later bankrupt clients) error rates over an 11‑year period, comparing Big 4 to non‑Big 4 and national second‑tier to regional/local third‑tier firms. Big 4 firms exhibit significantly lower type I and type II error rates than non‑Big 4 firms, while no significant difference exists between second‑tier and third‑tier firms, confirming a Big 4 quality advantage in going‑concern reporting.

Abstract

Prior research suggests that the Big 4 audit firms are of higher quality than are non-Big 4 firms. However, existing tests for an association between audit firm size and reporting accuracy are indirect and provide mixed results. Our study extends this line of research by examining whether the Big 4 audit firms exhibit higher quality reporting by having fewer “audit-reporting errors” in the context of issuing going-concern modified reports. Our analyses examine both types of going-concern reporting errors (i.e., type I errors—modified opinions rendered to subsequently viable clients; and type II errors—unmodified opinions rendered to subsequently bankrupt clients) over an 11-year period. We also examine reporting error rate differences between the national second-tier firms and regional/local third-tier firms. Our findings indicate that both type I and type II error rates for Big 4 audit firms are significantly lower compared to non-Big 4 firms. In contrast, we find no significant differences between the national second-tier and regional/local third-tier audit firms with respect to either type of reporting error. Our results provide evidence about a Big 4 audit quality difference in reporting on client's going-concern problems.

References

27