Prerequisites Versus Diffusion: Testing Alternative Explanations of Social Security Adoption

David Collier, Richard E. Messick

American Political Science Review · 1975 · 83 citations · 19 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Cross‑national research has largely focused on within‑nation causal relations, but diffusion effects among nations must also be considered. The study aims to combine prerequisites and diffusion perspectives to examine the timing of first social security adoption across nations. It analyzes the timing of first adoption of social security in each country, integrating both within‑nation and cross‑nation diffusion factors. The results show that both prerequisites and diffusion effects shape adoption patterns, with later adopters adopting at lower levels of modernization due to a larger state role in developing countries and the distinctive characteristics of social security.

Abstract

Cross-national research has, with a few exceptions, dealt exclusively with hypotheses that focus on causal relations within nations. It is increasingly clear both on substantive and methodological grounds, however, that diffusion effects among nations must also be considered. The present research combines these alternative perspectives in an analysis of the timing of the first adoption of social security in nations. It is found that not only prerequisites explanations—which focus on causes within each nation—but also spatial and hierarchical diffusion effects must be considered in explaining patterns of social security adoption. The most important overall pattern, which appears to result from diffusion, is the tendency for later adopters to adopt at lower levels of modernization. This finding is interpreted as being due in part to a general tendency toward a larger role of the state in later developing countries—involving an important difference in the sequence in which different aspects of modernization occur—and in part to special characteristics of social security as a public policy.

References

19