Ecology · 1992 · 58 citations · 22 references
Life SciencesEcologyPlant SciencesInsect EcologyPlant PhysiologyPlant-microbe InteractionsChemical Defense In PlantsHerbivory EcologyInsect-plant InteractionsPlant Defense ResponsesPlant-herbivore InteractionsPlant-insect InteractionsDefense Response MechanismsInsect Herbivore ResistancePlant Defense CompoundsPlant Defense MechanismsPlant Resistance To InsectsPlant-herbivore Defense CoevolutionPredationSpecialist Herbivores
Plants in the same genus often differ by certain putative defense compounds even though they are attacked by the same or similar herbivores. We compared two such congeners in their interactions with the same seed predators. In the Sonoran Desert, seeds of the palo verdes Cercidium floridum and C. microphyllum (Leguminosae) were fed upon by the bruchid beetles Mimosestes amicus, M. ulkei, and Stator limbatus, several species of imperfect soil fungi, and at least one species of termite. Seed suitability was compared in field and laboratory experiments. Seeds of C. floridum were significantly more resistant except to a putative subpopulation of S. limbatus that normally feeds on C. floridum. Cercidium floridum seed resistance was located in the seed coat and was chemically based, as determined by a seed boat removal experiment and experiments in which we transferred extracts from resistant seeds to susceptible seeds. The resistance chemical(s) was not identified, though tests for tannins were negative. Alternatively, C. microphyllum abscised pods early, which significantly reduced attack by the seed predators. Early pod abscission was more effective at reducing seed predation than were resistant seed coats. We suggest that very different plant defense mechanisms may evolve under similar selection pressures within the same lineage, contrary to conventional wisdom.
22
Resource Availability and Plant Antiherbivore Defense
Phyllis D. Coley, John P. Bryant, F. Stuart Chapin · Science · 1985 · 4K citations
Differentiation of Populations
Arthur M. Shapiro · Science · 1970 · 619 citations
Radial diffusion method for determining tannin in plant extracts
Ann Hagerman · Journal of Chemical Ecology · 1987 · 532 citations
Agriculture, Botany, Plant Sciences +12