Dimensions of the Precautionary Principle

Per Sandin

Human and Ecological Risk Assessment An International Journal · 1999 · 409 citations · 9 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The essay proposes an analytical apparatus for an authoritative formulation of the Precautionary Principle and recommends using a four‑dimensional if‑clause in negotiations. The authors examine multiple formulations of the Precautionary Principle and identify four dimensions—threat, uncertainty, action, and command. They recast the principle as an if‑clause incorporating the four dimensions, noting that the weakest dimension dictates the overall strength. Keywords: Precautionary Principle, precaution, uncertainty.

Abstract

Abstract This essay attempts to provide an analytical apparatus which may be used for finding an authoritative formulation1 of the Precautionary Principle. Several formulations of the Precautionary Principle are examined. Four dimensions of the principle are identified: (1) the threat dimension, (2) the uncertainty dimension, (3) the action dimension, and (4) the command dimension. It is argued that the Precautionary Principle can be recast into the following if-clause, containing these four dimensions: “If there is (1) a threat, which is (2) uncertain, then (3) some kind of action (4) is mandatory.” The phrases expressing these dimensions may vary in (a) precision and (b) strength. It is shown that it is the dimension containing the weakest phrase that determines the strength of the entire principle. It is suggested that the four-dimensional if-clause be used as an analytical apparatus in negotiations of the Precautionary Principle. Keywords: Precautionary Principleprecautionuncertainty

References

9