Colon perforation during colonoscopy: Surgical <i>versus</i> conservative management

Claire Hall, N J Dorricott, I A Donovan, John P. Neoptolemos

British journal of surgery · 1991 · 136 citations · 16 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Conservative treatment is advised for well‑prepared patients unless a large perforation or underlying carcinoma is present. A survey of 14 endoscopy units in the West Midlands, UK, collected data on how colonic perforations during colonoscopy are managed. Among 17,500 colonoscopies, 15 perforations (0.09%) were reported; most were diagnosed immediately, with management ranging from simple oversew to resection, oversew, conservative treatment, or drainage with colostomy, and none resulted in significant morbidity.

Abstract

Abstract A survey of endoscopy units in the West Midlands, UK, was undertaken to ascertain the management of colonic perforation during colonoscopy. Fifteen perforations were reported from a total of 17 500 colonoscopies performed in 14 units (a rate of 0.09 per cent). In seven patients the diagnosis was suspected or diagnosed immediately and in the remaining eight 2–72 h later. Four patients with associated pathology (carcinoma, Crohn's disease, ulcerative colitis and a polyp) had resection and primary anastomosis. Seven patients had a simple oversew, four of these having had a delayed diagnosis. In four cases the site of perforation was not identified, but only one patient had conservative treatment. Three patients had drainage and a defunctioning colostomy. There was no significant morbidity following treatment. It is recommended that patients who have had a good bowel preparation should be treated conservatively unless there is a large perforation or an underlying carcinoma.

References

16