Competitive Effects and Responses Between Plant Species in a First‐Year Old‐Field Community

Thomas E. Miller, Patricia A. Werner

Ecology · 1987 · 225 citations · 20 references

Concepts

Abstract

Competitive interactions involve two separate processes: the effect of a species on others in the community and the response of a species to all others. Five species from a 1st—yr field were investigated to determine if there is any correlation between competitive effect and response and if the patterns of effect and response can explain the relative success of each species in the full community. Effect and response were measured by observing the growth of individuals in all possible monocultures and two—species mixtures, using ambient densities (Year 1) and a range of densities (Year 2) for each species. Both monocultures and two—species mixtures were obtained by removing unwanted individuals at emergence, leaving naturally emerging individuals of the desired species. Competitive effect and response were found to be inversely correlated. The inverse correlation lead to a hierarchy of competitive ability, with Ambrosia artemisiifolia being the competitive dominant, followed by Agropyron repens, Plantago lanceolata, and finally the competitive subordinates Chenopodium album. Lepidium campestre (used in Year 1), and Trifolium repens (used in Year 2). The interactions were generally asymmetric, e.g. Ambrosia artemisiifolia had a large suppressive effect on the other species and demonstrated no response to their presence. The hierarchy and a lack of specificity of the interactions suggest that all the species are limited by, and competing for, the same resource or resources. The hierarchy of competitive ability appears to be a major factor in determining the abundance of each species in the full community.

References

20