The Historicity of Romantic Discourse.

Margaret Russett, Clifford Siskin

MLN · 1989 · 287 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Romantic discourse is portrayed as a culture‑specific, evolving self‑concept whose critique reshapes how readers view Romantic writers and their modern critics. The study traces how historical notions of self and behavior were reframed as natural truths and examines how this reframing serves political ends by linking Romantic knowledge to social, professional, and economic power. The author traces the historical shift of self and behavior concepts into natural truths, linking Romantic knowledge production to social, professional, and economic power structures.

Abstract

This provocative critique of Romantic discourse will profoundly affect how readers perceive not only the Romantic writers, but also their most celebrated modern critics - such as de Man, Hartman, and McGann - who are, the author argues, themselves unwitting captives of the ideas and writings they criticize. With the Romantic redefinition of the self as a mind that grows, writing became an expressive index to that growth: the product, as we still understand it, of a developing creative imagination. Siskin argues that this imaginative mind is not a timeless producer, but a culture-specific product, not knowledge discovered in the course of mankind's inevitable progress, as Wordsworth and Keats claimed, but knowledge made at a particular point in time. As he traces the transformation of historical concepts of self and behaviour into 'natural truths', Siskin performs the political task of relating the production and reproduction of the Romantic knowledge to the workings of social, professional, and economic power. Scholars and students of English literature of the Romantic period, or of Romanticism generally.