Why don't families get along with eco-feedback technologies?

Mary Barreto, Evangelos Karapanos, Nuno Nunes

2013 · 30 citations · 14 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Eco‑feedback domestic technologies have gained momentum over the last decade, yet family acceptance remains limited despite many prototypes and commercial products. The study reports on interviews with 15 dual‑income families during a year‑long deployment of an eco‑feedback system to investigate factors preventing adoption, and proposes three phases—orientation, incorporation, and social integration—to explain adoption barriers. The authors conducted a year‑long deployment of an eco‑feedback technology with 15 dual‑income families, collecting interview data to identify adoption barriers and to develop a three‑phase model of orientation, incorporation, and social integration. Non‑adoption was traced to systemic failures in physical context, social dynamics, family roles, priorities, and rigid routines.

Abstract

Eco-feedback domestic technologies have gained momentum over the last decade. Yet, while a wide range of research prototypes and commercial products has been proposed, their acceptance by families is still limited. In this paper we report on our findings from interviews with 15 dual income families, during a year-long deployment of an eco-feedback technology that attempted to inquire into the factors that prohibited its adoption. We found the non-adoption of our system to be rooted in a number of systemic failures, relating to the physical context, the families' social dynamics and the roles assumed by family members, as well as families' priorities and the non-negotiability of their routines. Motivated by prior work and our empirical findings we propose three distinct dimensions but also phases in the adoption of eco-feedback technologies: orientation, incorporation and social integration, and discuss how these may hint at different barriers in the adoption of eco-feedback technologies.

References

14