The Potential for Insect-Population Suppression by Dominant Conditional Lethal Traits1

Waldemar Klassen, E. F. Knipling, J. U. McGuire

Annals of the Entomological Society of America · 1970 · 31 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Calculations are presented to show the possibility of suppressing insect populations by overflooding a native population with individuals bearing dominant conditional lethal traits. If a conditional lethal trait is determined by a single dominant factor fully penetrant in the heterozygotes, then a native population of 100 insects per acre could be eradicated by 3 releases of 12 mutants for every insect in the native population. Comparable results would be achieved with a polyfactorial conditional lethal trait if the hybrids differed from the native population. Since inability to diapause is considered to be an ideal conditional lethal trait for control, hypothetical population models were worked out to determine the impact of releasing boll weevils, Anthonomus grandis Boheman, carrying an assumed dominant nondiapause trait. If a natural population were reduced by a special schedule of treatments with insecticides to 1 male and 1 female per acre and then overflooded by a factor of 99 of each sex, all carrying the dominant conditional lethal trait, the overwintering population (F4 generation) would be reduced by 99.99%. This reduction would constitute practical eradication. An alternate procedure involving the use of a similar nondiapausing strain that was partially sterilized by irradiation or chemosterilants would avoid economic damage to cotton pending the final eradication of the pest by the conditional lethal trait. In this hypothetical model, a small natural population would be initially overflooded 99:1, and such releases would be continued for 4 generations. The natural population would be effectively suppressed by sterility while the dominant conditional lethal genes were being introduced into the natural population often enough to assure extinction of the population during the winter. The estimated costs show that it will be entirely practical to use these genetic methods for eradication if they can be perfected.