Noûs · 2014 · 84 citations · 25 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyMistakePhilosophy Of MindPhilosophy Of ScienceModal LogicScientific RealismA Posteriori NecessityMetaphysical ModalityMetaphysical PossibilityModal EpistemologyProblem Of Error
Before Kripke and Putnam, most philosophers accepted that a posteriori identities were contingent; it was, after all, very easy to imagine the falsity of any a posteriori identity. It seems fair to say that Kripke (1971, 1980) revolutionized how we understand the relationship between epistemology and modality. He argued persuasively for the necessity of identity and hence that even identities discovered a posteriori, like water = H2O, turn out to be necessary, not contingent. This is now the received wisdom. Let us assume that philosophers were convinced to accept a correct conclusion: there are a posteriori necessities of the kind that Kripke and Putnam cite. When we unpack Yablo's answer to this question, and examine how he thinks we ascertain that a situation is impossible, we will see that while Yablo concedes the answer to the first question may be “yes,” he answers “no” to second. In this paper I argue that Kripke and Yablo are both mistaken about imagination. The answer to both questions is “yes:” it is easy to imagine impossible situations, including situations deemed impossible only a posteriori, even after we acknowledge that they are impossible. I first establish that Kripke in fact answers “no” to the first question (§1). I will then explain why I think that is a mistake, why it is plausible that we can imagine the impossible (§2). That discussion will also lay the groundwork for examining Yablo's elaborations of Kripke's views; I will argue that Yablo's view of imagination also doesn't stand up to scrutiny (§3).1 At this point I will have shown that Kripke and Yablo hold implausible views about imagination. One might think we nevertheless must accept this implausible view it the for a to in the of a posteriori we imagine the impossible, how can we to to for I will a that how we can imagine the impossible, the very for that are for I how a to Kripke's discussion of the for the of and The view I to Kripke is about The I Kripke to have in like us about and we only is and imagination us about and we imagine only is of imagination a we this the view of the view of imagine the impossible. Kripke about the necessity of a posteriori to like we can imagine impossible The seems to impossible He that he to explain Kripke's we not imagine impossible, we imagine a situation that is to the to be mistaken for This is about Kripke's of it of Kripke's why he thinks we answer we see in the the situation we imagine is a we are a about situation it about we In this I to establish that Kripke the are for Kripke's have it will be to see and how he the I have that philosophers question, think a answer to the plausible we to be impossible we and only it in the a situation is impossible, there is to of we might we think a situation is then we imagine it is to that “no” answers to and to the in a for to Yablo's of Kripke's will Yablo's view in we imagine to we imagine to this is that that it is of have and not have of can imagine discovered that it of we that this is a of this is the very of the of it is the I see it is imagine that this might have to have of Kripke not he imagine this very of is to be of he the of he might have he imagine it of now that he that the is of he he he that it is might Kripke have to answer “no” to in the we imagine the impossible, only we it that is why Kripke like that it is of we a situation is impossible we can imagine the answer to is “yes,” the answer to is that is the then Kripke to Yablo's we will to in In this I the “no” answer to to hold that we are in that we can imagine that there have He to that we think we can see to be are in fact not He to that we can imagine are not in fact we can This is of the Kripke the in imagination and a The is that Kripke Kripke's is to argue for the of a posteriori we say that it is for to have that that this have of Kripke The is we can and Kripke between not to is the first is When we to the it is that Kripke to say about imagine not to and this of He the about Kripke's of the fact that he the is we are to it out to the is for we are in for we for we for that Kripke doesn't the we mistaken about we imagine we imagine That is why Kripke can imagine discovered that of we imagine the is we for it is to to that kind of I this is Kripke it to the The point of is to of the not to the Kripke situations might have Kripke's about that in a situation the is not of the is not of we imagine situation to we imagine a situation in of is not of is The it In that situation there is water there is that is When Kripke that we can imagine that water is not H2O, he is we imagine it out that water is not This is the Let the in a that why I think the view is that water is H2O, and also that water is acknowledge that not the be it seems that can imagine imagine that water is not H2O, imagine it out that water is not Kripke we to be that water is not H2O, we are That is not we imagine a situation in to the situation is Kripke that we not imagine the impossible situation we to I there is that Kripke and to the about the and epistemology for a how plausible are and plausible is it that we imagine impossible situations, and that we about we imagine we I not about imagination us of the answer to is I will and explain a of that for to be they will have to situations that are to be impossible. will also lay the groundwork for discussion of The and a view that answers to I will a in how they of we think we impossible situations, even we were of and even we the situations were they a for we examine in that we are not about we are up the and imagine When he and out to be not I imagine It to that I this I must have That is a were not he is about The that in very like the first are a that out to be a are and that is The will that now I imagine that It to that I a is a I must not have after That seems like a were not might and that were a think there is about that to the not are a the of about the necessity of That seems The only to hold a view is a to like a we is a imagination out of a we When we think about imagination it how we can impossible we that to impossible the fact that the is impossible not the that we understand the that we are about we imagine I imagine even I have I of a That not it that that the this is The question of how I I that it is I this point When there is that is and not a of a of the a we imagine there is that we have that The about and including to imagine the impossible. be is a that in the a is a is the to in a a of we a between the and we imagine that the is in for the even of the we have to imagine impossible, that to the the is not When we to the we might that the situation is not we are that will not us the in imagination. might that the situation we are is impossible, we the and imagine of might the we in there is we can to the it not the it I that we and how we imagine we imagine out to be a it is plausible that we can imagine the impossible. Let now to the I imagine the for they to be the most It is that I imagine I that have that I have I imagine that the I not kind of have a I I can also in a I can imagine this were to it be a most the to be That is not any I not imagine any in I and say and that I have to In we imagine in there are a of in to we to will to imagine a will imagine a that only seems to have the of a in the in question we imagine a in there is a of to that of the of are to the of to that a of that of have to be in the Let imagination in the of we have any to that a of are He that situations are in for the situation to be there must be of and the that philosophers to in about the of and thinks this is to to we that we can I in how plausible is in view like of this The that to imagine any situation we to imagine be that not imagine the to the of we imagine a to the of we to imagine the the and the of that the to be in the It seems that we can imagine situations to the of the that very of that thinks philosophers can imagine a a to imagine how I that we the and that both are in the the of is that This imagination be a kind of is to it be a imagination. it is to see how to the to of we impossible, that be I imagine in this is this it be for be imagination to us I and are The a to understand the in there is about situations that turn out to be impossible. I will a of the that will explain how we impossible in are of and we are not about the of the and it is see a is is that Kripke's can the for a Kripke's were and to lay out a of imagination a Yablo that of and are that is they are Kripke's point be that we imagine impossible to imagine out to be impossible situation is of that a to the and we might this the the In this I will Yablo's of the argue that he must implausible about imagination. that I is that that In is of a impossible Yablo that we not the the we can imagine that are in the that of and of we can imagine the see how Yablo to the we have The might very have they only they were of the fact that is we imagine to be we they were it that is now not now we that = that we the most philosophers and imagine they to be In this they were of the that Kripke = then = of this that the doesn't us to the for philosophers of Kripke's may imagine they the they both the and that = then the we imagine imagine situation that we for in can imagine the impossible situation of only he that is not he is of for the necessity of Yablo's is that it is The we can is imagine a situation in the of a to between and us that the is in fact a Yablo that is not is it Yablo I examine in in like water = H2O, are to be like can imagine only in of the fact that water = of the fact that water = H2O, then = When we to imagine that water is we are a situation and it for in water This is a to point out of Yablo's When impossible seems that is have the the in a say in the and the and then have the in the situation not have the that water is not H2O, are not that water is not Yablo a of like is The not for I I will argue that Yablo's of of is is is might not can imagine it Yablo's for the I in In of Yablo's we to imagine the At first it I explain the in this I will then the the will that Yablo's be the in then the fact that the and the then were to imagine water = and Yablo's is to imagine impossible situations is not of a fact a In this not be In we imagine that a to after all, even we the the point of is to imagine that not there is to accept Yablo's that of a of the we This of the to imagination. might Yablo Yablo's The first we might the I will that in the The is a of the we in I will that in I will argue that Yablo to the fact that we can imagine the impossible. Yablo might that while we can imagine the are we imagine that water while water = we that water = then we imagine that water that Yablo this he how we establish the The is to it is to the we the and see we the the we the then we accept the In the the a we a view about how we a the of the Yablo that we to imagine the we are to imagine it the of the then we accept the I The first to Yablo's for the that I not the I question is Yablo's that we the the of the for Yablo to be is is that even Yablo were about how we it be of to Let us the first Yablo's we to be about we are to When we are to that and then to imagine we are not to imagine and the = Yablo not that we to imagine a The the not the even that we to be are to be are can that and imagine that that are imagine a the that that I imagine that I imagine that I I I the of a it is that we are not to the the it to see the can I not that = and imagine out to be he I for that = and then a in it out that imagination that is are why and how fact this the the like and we have it is to a we are to first the the that that is to imagine that he is The then be this there in we that and we that and we accept the then I there are that is imagine The answer seems to be the to the The answer even are convinced Kripke's that not that in is imagine that a of he is the a I the answer is The point of the is to to imagine I in that is impossible might the it doesn't it the that is not It seems to imagine that imagine that he he to The fact that I accept the necessity of not that in a When I Putnam, can I imagine that is a It seems that I I can imagine it out that is in the a I might this that this that I is a I can this convinced that are not In of the impossible situation even the of the seems to imagine that the and the that I not to argue that the that in to that Yablo not us a to establish the and for that it is to that in a of the of this I that identity it are the Yablo for to I that is it might then be to imagine for water = H2O, = and this seems to be a of not of Yablo to in and the that it I that we Yablo's for the that I not the I Yablo's for how we a the of the are in even we that and accept that then we can imagine that I have argued that we in the that I the is and we that we will that this Yablo's for I not see that it Yablo be that we that and that to imagine that then the then we will that fact about we can imagine the in it about we can imagine we even the in this is it may not to that and then imagine that are about that the I argued in even we that we can imagine about I that I in I can imagine about that and can even explain why I hold the that I in That is of the that the When we are not in we will the I in of this One is how we establish That of Yablo's for we accept Yablo's for how we establish that about and of that is I that the to Yablo the fact that we imagine first like the of the in they are impossible. to we were were not we we I argued in the discussion of is In to in the of imagination is to for it a in we this of the of will this first examine Yablo's of the Yablo's of and see how it first we to a we it is the this is how it is that any can the of the impossible, the to about it is to that between to imagine the correct is that is in fact the of I have a and This is Yablo that in the Yablo that imagination will not the between and hence I imagine a it is we a to that a be a it not that a is imagination to will us to like we of that a a to to the of we us that are impossible, to like it that the in are even we to be the we have to think that the of is to about the we have to think the of us are of and the like of In philosophers that of to I that to we can to we to be of I have argued that the answer to is we can imagine impossible I have also argued that the answer to is we can imagine impossible situations even after we that they are impossible. of that it is easy to that in it is also easy to that in impossible. I have a for explain why is that we imagine the impossible. That will be a for to might that discussion Kripke's about The is the we have and a posteriori even the view is the we have that not the and it not that Kripke a view of The paper the now I to how a of the The the between and The how we imagine the impossible. this us about Kripke is about a posteriori we have to that are for Let us turn to that view in this is to of imagination that us we the view the can the view that we imagine the impossible Kripke's about a posteriori necessities we have to that are for I will in I will a of imagination and to we can imagine the impossible. The the epistemology for and how we can a posteriori and In the I how a Kripke's a a discussion of how will kind of for in When imagine the to the first in a and a and the the we the of a to of the the That is for and that the is That the it The of is the are about the In to and that were also the about were that in the are the is a it will I will of imagination that I have out view of the of I assume that have that in a and of the that we might say we are they the of and in the and In for we are of and imagination also When imagine the a out in of the it is in a for imagine that in the are up the in the and are and and the in the and and imagine a for the the in the of the to the to the The in the imagine the In the it is that is the that are the and that it is the of the be a about is to The in the the the and the they have In I up a The a a and this is This not have to examine and the in the the are kind of of will have a that a of the is the the is and the are the be to and then the might that is that is and is that is and is kind of is that and that of the not in the they in about the situation that it is about in the When I imagine that and I the of the the and the the are the and That the are is in the The is a of to and any of this is the and about the the It also and are of the how this out in think of a of like that are and a the have like that a the is both and That is the One to The a of that is a we first up and then to the and about not this there is The The view I is a of imagination. are up out of this view of imagination us understand to imagine the The is are of imagination and we can is the in situation to of can for that a that the were the that a I can that the I is I can this not only can I imagine I can imagine that is both and like of the the The that is is of the impossible. imagine impossible situations of of In we the between the and we that the in for and that the even I imagine that I have I that the the That is I not imagine kind of the of that That is a very I imagine that I to a The for I imagine imagine I a in a and this I a in and I see in the the This is very like and in the I a in and the I I imagine I this In this I also the and that of the we is of the impossible. The of how impossible situations is we of about situations, we can is about to imagine impossible This of we can imagine impossible situations, doesn't that to philosophers for I to now that we accept this can of Kripke's about a posteriori explain to and to how we impossible situations in imagination. the might have is the that for The and views view of we can we accept of is that are not we can see this first and then after the fact we were were not we we imagination for it a in It is to have for is are In the is that the impossible a situation in is will not be to in the situation the The is that are and there are have we accept this first we are to It seems to be for that we are imagine the of be we are we imagine can we a that is both and is kind of we can the any for any we can imagine that for it to between and impossible be I to accept there are we are even It is to imagine that = for is a that the is I the to have all, for there to be is This kind of the and very I will assume that the very I we for we will be to imagine This a plausible In that a is we a of to imagine a for it to be that are there even this of I that I have I not of I can imagine a in I the I that = I can imagine for it to be Let be we are to establish The fact that we and hence are of the to in the for is of us to of it the of It be very of be is to of the very can be how can to be in the be for we that is to to be in the for of not they may for for the it is only of that is to and in the and the then this not for there may be they also to that are for Let that the that are this not for there are we can imagine including = there are the situation not for we have to that for in how the to and a a between the and we that the is in for the to be of we have to imagine that first of the and we is in the The it is this that it is for to When I imagine the for that I that the The is I imagine the I that correct In the is and I have it that is and I have are that be a is for turn to a posteriori is and the In we the identity of the that this is and that the very is that the is and the is In in the the identity not In the the that can be both and in the the that is that be it that it is that In that water is not say we imagine a the and the out of the and to this the kind of we have to the and we have to that the The fact that in the situation water then the to this that water be not I have a imagination for is also a and of imagination. about in a about for I argue that it a to have this not a are the in a and the and a to it not in that a have that the is the and are in that a is imagination. imagine that a in the have to imagine that it is the The fact that in is not it is the that this not any for situations can be for that it is for to that is like in the that is the have that then can a in and have for will this of for might that in a that not the in might be we have for the is is is this is how we like and In this paper I stand there are I have there will epistemology might the a and a I that like a and it I that a this doesn't I that be a that both that the is and that it is a In fact I about the that while I have that like a must this It that a situation is like a and of I not have for I that discussion for the of this that I have a plausible of imagination and how it and Kripke's about a posteriori also for that Kripke that is for the of also that discussion Kripke's for a posteriori In this most of Kripke's the of a and Kripke out for the of a posteriori not The of water = this of and to that he to explain the the and it epistemology Kripke's that while I have that a for imagination a to the view is about in the most of the in I have shown that there is a to the of I have not argued that this is the epistemology is have I shown how the can accepted are a for This up discussion of now have a and necessity that Kripke's about a posteriori we can impossible in imagination we have to for we the view the implausible the I in we can say that Kripke to say the implausible we can say that Kripke to might view is a of Kripke's he we he is that we to be he that we imagine in a that is for I it is this Kripke to about we and he in that is impossible to that the is I can that is not a of the a very Kripke's a about is of that is in a for a that are plausible that are that not the The of the not the is to imagine a a that In of the even that we imagine we imagine it to imagine a very for for The for is in the of to the of the a that the is now we have the Let us see how in imagine I in that like it I imagine this a a now and a of I imagine that is not is it is like to be it is for I have to imagine are that is a of and that I this a situation both and is not to imagine a for I imagine like and is to have I have not a is The of is the that there is that is a of and that the the that this that are This a Kripke's this Let be about I When we imagine a the that that are may be to imagine in it may be are the to the to that is is the Kripke the of and The is it is for to any for to The the turn out to be and in I that for It not us that we imagine impossible situations were it not for the have that can a the of views in a philosophers must philosophers to argue that are are to very about of imagination. to and to up of and imagine we not to for
25
Thomas Nagel · The Philosophical Review · 1974 · 6.8K citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Psychology +13
The conscious mind: in search of a fundamental theory
Choice Reviews Online · 1996 · 4.2K citations
Humanities, Neuroscience, Psychology +11
From metaphysics to ethics: a defence of conceptual analysis
Choice Reviews Online · 1999 · 1.5K citations
Humanities, Philosophy, Ethics +10
V. A. Howard · International Studies in Philosophy · 1993 · 867 citations
Is Conceivability a Guide to Possibility?
Stephen Yablo · Philosophy and Phenomenological Research · 1993 · 737 citations