Understanding Random Forests: From Theory to Practice

TLDR

Machine learning is increasingly integral to scientific analysis, yet it must be approached with an understanding of algorithmic mechanisms to avoid black‑box pitfalls. This thesis aims to dissect random forests to illuminate their learning mechanisms, internal structure, and interpretability. The study analyzes tree induction, ensemble construction, computational complexity, and Scikit‑Learn implementation of random forests, and theoretically characterizes the Mean Decrease of Impurity variable‑importance measure. The analysis demonstrates that variable importance measures derived from random forests possess the expected theoretical properties.

Abstract

Data analysis and machine learning have become an integrative part of the modern scientific methodology, offering automated procedures for the prediction of a phenomenon based on past observations, unraveling underlying patterns in data and providing insights about the problem. Yet, caution should avoid using machine learning as a black-box tool, but rather consider it as a methodology, with a rational thought process that is entirely dependent on the problem under study. In particular, the use of algorithms should ideally require a reasonable understanding of their mechanisms, properties and limitations, in order to better apprehend and interpret their results. Accordingly, the goal of this thesis is to provide an in-depth analysis of random forests, consistently calling into question each and every part of the algorithm, in order to shed new light on its learning capabilities, inner workings and interpretability. The first part of this work studies the induction of decision trees and the construction of ensembles of randomized trees, motivating their design and purpose whenever possible. Our contributions follow with an original complexity analysis of random forests, showing their good computational performance and scalability, along with an in-depth discussion of their implementation details, as contributed within Scikit-Learn. In the second part of this work, we analyse and discuss the interpretability of random forests in the eyes of variable importance measures. The core of our contributions rests in the theoretical characterization of the Mean Decrease of Impurity variable importance measure, from which we prove and derive some of its properties in the case of multiway totally randomized trees and in asymptotic conditions. In consequence of this work, our analysis demonstrates that variable importances [...].