Journal of Lipid Research · 2003 · 109 citations · 11 references
MedicineAnatomyCell BiologyBiomedical ImagingHistologyMicroscopic AnatomyAdipose TissueBody CompositionMicroscopic Cell MorphologyMicroscopic ExaminationStaining TechniquesAbdominal MorphometricsAbdominal Visceral FatAutomated MicroscopyBiomedical MicroscopyDigital Image AnalysisFat Content MeasurementMicroscope ImagingSubcutaneous Adipose Tissue
Mean diameters of fat cells from abdominal tissues from 31 volunteers were determined by three methods based on fat cell isolation after collagenase digestion and methylene blue staining. The three methods were direct microscopy (Micro), manual measurement of diameters from digital images by using the public domain NIH Image program (Scion), and automated measurement of diameters from digital images using a customized program developed by Biomedical Imaging Resource at Mayo Clinic (AdCount). There was excellent agreement between the methods' measurement of mean abdominal fat cell diameter (concordance correlation coefficient >0.84). The Scion method gave slightly but systematically lower mean abdominal fat cell diameters than did either AdCount or Micro. The AdCount approach produced results that are comparable to those from Micro. Comparison of AdCount and Micro in measuring diameters of fat cells from thigh confirmed the good comparability between the two methods independent of fat depot.AdCount is very reliable, and the quickest and most objective of the three methods in measuring fat cell diameters from various depots. Mean diameters of fat cells from abdominal tissues from 31 volunteers were determined by three methods based on fat cell isolation after collagenase digestion and methylene blue staining. The three methods were direct microscopy (Micro), manual measurement of diameters from digital images by using the public domain NIH Image program (Scion), and automated measurement of diameters from digital images using a customized program developed by Biomedical Imaging Resource at Mayo Clinic (AdCount). There was excellent agreement between the methods' measurement of mean abdominal fat cell diameter (concordance correlation coefficient >0.84). The Scion method gave slightly but systematically lower mean abdominal fat cell diameters than did either AdCount or Micro. The AdCount approach produced results that are comparable to those from Micro. Comparison of AdCount and Micro in measuring diameters of fat cells from thigh confirmed the good comparability between the two methods independent of fat depot. AdCount is very reliable, and the quickest and most objective of the three methods in measuring fat cell diameters from various depots. One of the routine variables of interest for researchers of adipose tissue physiology is adipocyte size, which is commonly measured as fat cell diameter using light microscopy (Micro). From the diameter, mean fat cell volume and lipid content are derived mathematically. This technique requires collagenase digestion of the adipose tissue sample, separating adipocytes by centrifugation, methylene blue staining to identify the nuclei, and subsequent microscopic measurement of the diameter (1Di Girolamo M. Mendlinger S. Fertig J.W. A simple method to determine fat cell size and number in four mammalian species.Am. J. Physiol. 1971; 221: 850-858Crossref PubMed Scopus (271) Google Scholar). Although inexpensive and faster, this method results in considerable eyestrain when large numbers of samples must be processed and produces no permanent visual record. Attempts to circumvent these inconveniences by taking photomicrographs have been suggested (2Ashwell M. Priest P. Bondoux M. Sowter C. McPherson C.K. Human fat cell sizing—a quick, simple method.J. Lipid Res. 1976; 17: 190-192Abstract Full Text PDF PubMed Google Scholar). Photomicrographs provide visual records that can be analyzed at a later time but do not change the time required for the measurement procedure. In this report, we describe two techniques based upon computer analysis of digital images. The first method involved manually measuring fat cell diameters from digital images using NIH Image analysis software (Scion), similar to the photomicrographic method. Because this approach was actually more time-consuming than direct Micro, we developed another technique to further streamline and standardize measurements from digital images. A computer program for automated measurement of fat cell area from digital images and calculation of fat cell diameter, volume, and mass was developed at Mayo Clinic (AdCount). Mean diameters of fat cells obtained from abdominal tissue were determined and compared across three methods: direct Micro, Scion, and AdCount. To evaluate the comparability of AdCount with Micro when the source of fat cells is a different depot, mean diameters of fat cells from thigh were measured additionally by AdCount and Micro. The reliability of AdCount was tested by evaluating the reproducibility of the results when measured by one observer at two different times and by two observers once. Finally, after assessing the relation between the fat cell droplet size and cell maturity of very small fat cells using fluorescence Micro, we reassessed the effects of our choice of lipid droplet size on the estimated mean fat cell diameter. Twenty-six overweight and obese [body mass index (BMI) 27.5–36.8] and 14 lean (BMI 20–27) volunteers, all of whom had given informed written consent, participated in this study. Subcutaneous adipose tissue samples (200–600 mg) from the periumbilical area of 21 overweight and obese and 10 lean volunteers and from the thigh of four overweight and obese and five lean volunteers were obtained by needle biopsy. Tissue was digested in 1 mg/ml collagenase type II (Sigma C-6885) in HEPES buffer [0.1 M HEPES, 0.12 M NaCl, 0.05 M KCl, 0.005 M glucose, 1.5% w/v BSA, CaCl2 (pH 7.4)] in a 37°C water bath employing shaking at 115 rotations/min for 20–30 min. The cell suspension thus formed was centrifuged for 5 min at 300 g at room temperature. A 50–150 μl aliquot from the top layer was added to 450 μl of 0.2% methylene blue/HEPES solution for nuclei staining and incubated for 15 min at 37°C in the water bath. Five to 10 μl from the cell suspension were placed in each well of an 8-well glass slide, coverslipped, and measured optically using a Nikon Labophot 2/2A microscope equipped with an eyepiece having a 10 mm scaled reticle at phase contrast and 100× magnification. Next, cells were photographed using a Nikon Coolpix 990 digital camera attached to the microscope. Fat cells of at least 35 μm were measured by all methods. The diameters of at least 100 fat cells were defined optically by comparison with the scale from the reticle. The values were not recorded but appointed to groups that differ by 10 μm, creating a histogram with bins of 10 μm. The histograms were used to calculate the mean diameter and standard deviation of the mean diameter and to assess whether the distribution of adipocyte diameters was normal. Fat cells from the digital images were analyzed on a PC computer using the public domain image analysis program developed at the US National Institutes of Health (Scion). Briefly, the recorded images were resized to 45% by using Photo Editor software and saved in a TIFF format that is compatible with Scion. The modified images were then imported into the program, and a calibration was performed for each image by drawing a line over the scale that was introduced into the image field prior to digitization. Using the line tool, the diameters of at least 100 adipocytes were manually drawn and individually measured. The output of the measured diameters was transferred to an Excel program that was used for calculations of mean diameters and standard deviation and for creating histograms with 10 μm bins to check the normality of the data distribution. For the purpose of measuring the fat cell size, a stand-alone program designated AdCount was written by the Biomedical Imaging Resource, Mayo Clinic by using the comprehensive visualization workshop image-processing library developed and maintained by the Biomedical Imaging Resource, Mayo Clinic (3Hanson D.P. Robb R.A. Aharon S. Augustine K.E. Cameron B.M. Camp J.J. Karwoski R.A. Larson A.G. Stacey M.C. Workman E.L. New software toolkit for comprehensive visualization and analysis of three-dimensional multimodal biomedical images.J. Digit. Imaging. 1997; 10: 1-2Crossref PubMed Google Scholar). The choice of the parameters to be analyzed was based on the suggestions of DiGirolamo and Fine (4Di Girolamo M. Fine J.B. Cellularity measurements.Methods Mol. Biol. 2001; 155: 65-75PubMed Google Scholar). Each image is processed with an inhomogeneity correction filter to address the uneven illumination of the microscope field. The original image from the digital camera is imported into the AdCount program and a calibration performed as described for Scion (Fig. 1A). A threshold value is interactively determined to separate the cells from the background. A connected component algorithm is then applied to the image to define potential cells, and the area, diameter, and circularity measurements are computed. Predefined and changeable limits for the diameter and circularity measures further restrict the potential cells that are counted. The circularity measurement is computed as follows: Circularity = (P · P/A)/(4 · Pi), where P is the perimeter of the potential cell and A is its area. The circularity of a perfect circle is 1.0. The diameter of the circular cells is derived as follows: Diameter = 2 · sqrt(A/Pi). The area equivalent diameters are shown in Fig. 1B. Cells cut by the borders or with uneven edges resulting in a visual underestimation of the area may then be eliminated manually. After analysis, the program computes and displays a running total of counted cells, a histogram of the diameters of the counted cells, a numbered list of the individual diameters, the mean diameter, standard deviation of the diameters, heterogeneity of the fat cell population (standard deviation/mean), and mean lipid content. The program also delineates the measured cells with different colors and designates to each cell a number that corresponds to the number in the output of the results (Fig. 1C). The last helps in visualization of a cell of interest and its diameter. By clicking either on the cells or on a diameter value in the output, the program simultaneously highlights both. The output of the results is logged to a text file. Images were analyzed until ∼300 cells were sized. The Nile Red staining of lipid droplets was performed according to a published protocol (5Dorheim M.A. Sullivan M. Dandapani V. Wu X. Hudson J. Segarini P.R. Rosen D.M. Aulthouse A.L. Gimble J.M. Osteoblastic gene expression during adipogenesis in hematopoietic supporting murine bone marrow stromal cells.J. Cell. Physiol. 1993; 154: 317-328Crossref PubMed Scopus (173) Google Scholar) supplemented with nuclear counter-stain. Fat cells were isolated by collagenase digestion, washed in PBS, and fixed in 400 μl of 0.5% paraformaldehyde in PBS for 5 min. Meanwhile, a stock solution of Nile Red (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) prepared in DMSO (1 mg/ml) was diluted 1:100 in PBS (10× stock). Forty-four microliters of the 10× Nile Red stock was added to the fat cell suspension for 5 min. The nuclear staining was carried out for 5 min using a stock solution of Hoechst 33258 (Sigma-Aldrich) in water (10 mg/ml) diluted 1:20 in PBS (100× stock) with an aliquot added to a final concentration of 5 μg/ml Hoechst 33258. The cells were then washed three times with PBS. Five microliters of the fat cells in suspension were put on an 8-well glass slide and coverslipped. Fifty images of small, fluorescently labeled cells were collected immediately. The equipment and methods were as follows: an LSM510 Confocal Microscope (Carl Zeiss, Inc., Oberkochen, Germany) equipped with an Axiovert 100 M inverted microscope and an LD-Achroplan 40×/0.6na objective lens was used with an argon laser for excitation at 488 nm and emission using a 505–550 nm bandpass filter. The spectra settings may vary over a wide range, resulting in fluorescences of different colors (6Greenspan P. Mayer E.P. Fowler S.D. Nile red: a selective fluorescent stain for intracellular lipid droplets.J. Cell Biol. 1985; 100: 965-973Crossref PubMed Scopus (1858) Google Scholar). The settings we chose detected green fluorescence and gave a very good delineation of the fat droplets. The diameters of the fluorescent fat droplets of the unilocular cells and of the largest fat droplet in the multilocular cells were measured using an independent program, KS400 image analysis software (Carl Zeiss, Inc.). The populations of fat cells from 31 subcutaneous abdominal and nine femoral fat tissue samples were analyzed by the three methods. By necessity, the direct Micro method assayed a unique population of cells from each sample. The Scion and AdCount methods analyzed the same set of images, but the cells chosen for analysis were not controlled to be identical. The histograms obtained from the direct Micro and the raw data obtained by using both Scion and AdCount were used to calculate the mean fat cell diameter for each sample. The mean fat cell diameters were expressed in micrometers, rounded to a whole number, and then subjected to analysis of method comparisons. Method comparison was performed for each pair of methods from the three possible Micro Scion, AdCount Micro, and AdCount Scion for the abdominal fat depot. Method comparison for AdCount and Micro was performed for the femoral fat depot. For visual of the the from two methods were and a line of J.M. in the analysis of method comparison 1971; 221: Scholar) or a line A correlation coefficient to evaluate PubMed Scopus Google Scholar) was drawn the at The agreement between two methods was with correlation coefficient A correlation coefficient to evaluate PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). were based on a that both a of the line from the and a of each from the The of agreement was as excellent and The measurement of observer agreement for PubMed Scopus Google Scholar). Next, methods suggested by and J.M. in the analysis of method comparison 1971; 221: Scholar) were applied to the data to evaluate the and the of and The between two methods were for visual of and to and to whether was for the of to change with the of the The mean and the standard deviation of the of the and were The of was tested by a the reproducibility of measurements was for the AdCount method by correlation coefficient One observer measured the diameters of one cell from each of 31 abdominal samples at two different times and a observer measured the diameters of the same cells once. The results from the measurement by one observer were used to calculate the and the results from the measurement by the two observers were used to calculate the The line the diameters of abdominal adipocytes from the same by two methods the line of (Fig. of the for the abdominal adipocyte diameters had which an excellent For femoral AdCount Micro comparison had a of the between and excellent of for each mean of the two methods (Fig. on both of the the of of is that a number of and are the line and a for the Scion method to provide abdominal fat cell The mean and standard deviation of the a expression of and and the of are in The of the between AdCount or Micro and Scion methods are a for the Scion method to provide mean of the of that Scion method results that are different from the AdCount and from in the mean diameters of fat cells from two fat tissue depots. are given as mean automated measurement of diameters from digital images using a customized program developed by Biomedical Imaging Resource at Mayo Micro, Scion, manual measurement of diameters from digital images by using the public domain NIH Image = = Scion 0.05 from the of the of Scion 0.05 from the of the of mean diameters of fat cells, isolated after collagenase digestion of fat tissue from the of 31 volunteers were determined using three methods: direct Micro, Scion, and AdCount. The mean diameters of fat cells, isolated from femoral fat tissue of nine volunteers were determined with Micro and AdCount. between in were The mean and standard deviation of the were tested for automated measurement of diameters from digital images using a customized program developed by Biomedical Imaging Resource at Mayo Micro, Scion, manual measurement of diameters from digital images by using the public domain NIH Image P 0.05 from the of the of in a The mean diameters of fat cells, isolated after collagenase digestion of fat tissue from the of 31 volunteers were determined using three methods: direct Micro, Scion, and AdCount. The mean diameters of fat cells, isolated from femoral fat tissue of nine volunteers were determined with Micro and AdCount. between in were The mean and standard deviation of the were tested for the and were an excellent reproducibility of the AdCount that or observers do not to the in the measurements with the AdCount method. the images from the fluorescent staining for fat droplets with Nile Red and nuclei with Hoechst to the small fat cells into three used as of the number of lipid droplets in the cell the of the nuclei and the cells are shown in Fig. The first cells with fat droplets of the of we these to be adipocytes (Fig. The also multilocular cells, but with one of the droplets out as a diameters to μm for the as in Fig. fat Cells from these first two groups did not have a The to the fat droplets that were at a from the nuclei, and the nuclei may not have Cells we in the were of two those with fat but with the largest droplet having a diameter in the of μm, as in Fig. or a droplet with a diameter than μm, as in Fig. small fat A of this is that the cells had and volume by the lipid The nuclei also to be more and were in to the fat upon these we samples using AdCount with different lower limits for cell size The data were compared with an analysis using our original lower of 35 μm and with the records of the visual method for the same The same threshold on each was used that the change was the lower of cell size For the Micro, AdCount at 35 μm, and AdCount at μm cells, cells, and cells sample, were counted. The mean fat cell diameter for these samples was 10 μm, μm, and μm for the Micro, AdCount at 35 μm, and AdCount at μm, (P = for all a value for the lower of fat cell diameter not change the fat cell adipocyte diameter using light Micro is an reliable, and inexpensive to determine fat cell size (1Di Girolamo M. Mendlinger S. Fertig J.W. A simple method to determine fat cell size and number in four mammalian species.Am. J. Physiol. 1971; 221: 850-858Crossref PubMed Scopus (271) Google Scholar). not for a and more than a samples to be processed in one can be a and The of digital photomicrographs and image analysis software suggested to a to the time for fat cell and to provide a permanent for later our original approach using the Scion software actually required more time for Because of the simple of we software to the One of an automated software solution is the to size numbers of cells from each sample, at the same time the time for the of that the results from the automated software are comparable to the method. approach to measuring fat cell size and subsequent automated size by J. for the of adipose cell size in and Lipid Res. Full Text PDF PubMed Google Scholar). did not AdCount with this approach the of this J. for the of adipose cell size in and Lipid Res. Full Text PDF PubMed Google not to be commonly This may to the time required and the of the and that the agreement between methods for abdominal fat cell diameter was excellent = for all the comparisons. There was a agreement between AdCount and Micro for diameters of fat cells from thigh the small number for the nine for the a between Scion and either of the two mean diameters were using Scion Although both Scion and AdCount used the same set of digital images, actually different populations of AdCount measured over 300 cells with and in were measured using Scion and required more time than the direct Micro approach the mean fat cell diameters we measured by the Scion method have been for the compared with AdCount. measuring more cells for this but at the of an time that the Scion is also more than the AdCount approach in that a of is this is with AdCount. Finally, the the diameter the cell according to the visual AdCount the diameter of each cell from measurement of the cell area. The may be a approach when is in circularity of the The good agreement between AdCount and Micro in measuring thigh fat cells further the comparability between AdCount and Micro independent of adipose tissue depot. A potential to the of digital images is that the field of is with the manual method is possible to the on each cell to determine the cell diameter. The excellent agreement in diameter measurement of cells from and thigh and the of between AdCount and Micro that digital image analysis not in when compared with the manual method. the manual microscopic method is one can cells with lipid droplet diameters μm, the of fixed cells lipid droplets μm. of the of very small fat cells using the Nile Red with nuclear staining that cells with small fat droplets are of cells that may as may also have droplets of similar size and thus be adipocyte are The distribution of the size of these droplets and the of the nuclei of these cells in relation to the fat droplets very to these fat cells from fat droplets using the manual method. The diameter of an unilocular lipid droplet we detected using the Nile was μm, and that the diameter of the largest droplet in a multilocular small fat cells was μm. This that be to from fat cells when the diameter of the fat droplets is in the of μm to μm. may to the lower value for the diameter of fat cells to on the The of nuclei or in the of the fat droplets was and for small fat cells of at least 35 μm and as a of the choice of 35 μm. The of this was to the methods for measuring fat cell diameters, and value of the lower for the cells measured not the the same been used for all the methods. The AdCount program is and the to the limits of the diameter In we the of digital image analysis using Scion and AdCount to fat cell The approach a and permanent visual that can be at a Although Scion is at no the AdCount method is automated and min for measuring diameters of 300 fat AdCount potential in cells of size diameters determined by AdCount were in excellent agreement with those determined by Micro. fat cell based on automated digital images of fat cells measurement of fat cells from a large number of samples in a of The excellent reproducibility when the same observer performed two measurements or when two observers have performed one that AdCount can be a method in the of The algorithm and the used for and described in this have potential in biomedical A of this is as of the software its direct with cell or with as The of and this approach in the the of a digital camera and the and the time for comparisons. In our this is the that The are very to the Biomedical Imaging Resource at the Mayo Clinic for the software program for measuring fat cell diameters, to and for and to for with This was by and from the US Health automated measurement of diameters from digital images using a customized program developed by Biomedical Imaging Resource at Mayo Clinic microscopy manual measurement of diameters from digital images by using the public domain NIH Image program
11
The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data
J. Richard Landis, Gary G. Koch · Biometrics · 1977 · 78.9K citations · Full text
A Concordance Correlation Coefficient to Evaluate Reproducibility
Biometrics · 1989 · 8.7K citations
Methods for the determination of adipose cell size in man and animals
Jules Hirsch, E. Gallian · Journal of Lipid Research · 1968 · 892 citations · Full text
Medicine, Cell Biology, Physiology +13