The British counter-insurgency in Cyprus

Abstract

Abstract The Cyprus Emergency is often lumped together with Malaya and Kenya as an example of British counter-insurgency practice in the 1950s. Malaya and Kenya in particular are often used as models of how to succeed. The general perception is that these counter-insurgency campaigns, which are often connected with the strategy of ‘winning hearts and minds’, were highly successful,Footnote1 and have ‘become synonymous with the conduct of a successful counter-insurgency campaign’,Footnote2 in contrast with the methods employed by the French in Indo-China and Algeria, the Dutch in Indonesia, the Portuguese in Angola and Mozambique, the Americans in Vietnam, and the Soviets in Afghanistan. However, Cyprus, which tends to be comparatively neglected and less studied, presents a far less rosy and more problematic picture of British counter-insurgency practices in the 1950s. The geography and politics of Malaya and Kenya make them unsuitable as a model for counter-insurgency operations in the very different situation in Cyprus between 1954 and 1959. Rather than the usual comparison with Malaya and Kenya, Cyprus should be seen in parallel not only with Palestine, Aden, and Northern Ireland but also with Portugal and Rhodesia. Keywords: Cypruscounter-insurgencyEOKAGeorgios GrivasJohn Harding enosis intelligenceArchbishop Makarios Notes 1. CitationNewsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 1. 2. CitationBenest, ‘Aden to Northern Ireland 1966–76’, 119. 3. CitationHoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, viii. 4. CitationHoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, vii. 5. CitationPurdon, List the Bugle, 114. 6. CitationYoung, Four Five, 226. 7. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 19. 8. CitationXydis, ‘The UN General Assembly as an Instrument of Greek policy’, 141; CitationSouter, ‘An Island Apart: A Review of the Cyprus Problem’, 659. 9. Xydis, ‘The UN General Assembly as an Instrument of Greek policy’, 142. 10. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 19–20. 11. CitationGoldworthy, ‘Armed Struggle under late Colonialism’, 538–9. 12. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 84–5. 13. CitationEhrlich, ‘Cyprus, the “Warlike Isle”’, 1026–27. 14. CitationDevereux, Formulation of British Defence Policy, 174–5. 15. Holland, Britain and the Revolt in Cyprus, 32. 16. 531 House of Commons Debates (5th ser.), col. 507–8 (1954) quoted in Ehrlich, ‘Cyprus, the “Warlike Isle”’, 1029. 17. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 87. 18. Ehrlich, ‘Cyprus, the “Warlike Isle”’, 1028–9. 19. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 96. 20. CitationDewar, Brush Fire Wars, 68, 70. 21. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 88–9. 22. CitationGrob-Fitzgibbon, Imperial Endgame, 297. 23. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 90. 24. CitationCarver, War since 1945, 45–6. 25. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 90. 26. CitationFoley, The Memoirs of General Grivas, 66–7. 27. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 93. 28. CitationAllen, The Savage Wars of Peace, 139. 29. ‘First Light’, The Spectator 197, no. 6687 (24 August 1956), 252, quoted in CitationCarruthers, Winning Hearts and Minds, 200. 30. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 19. 31. CitationGodfrey, The History of the Suffolk Regiment, 138. 32. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 19. 33. Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 155. 34. Foley, The Memoirs of General Grivas, 76–77. 35. I.W.G. Martin, ‘The Cyprus Troubles, 1955–1960’, 25–6, Martin Papers, 91/32/1, Imperial War Museum [IWM] London. 36. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 105. 37. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 79–80. 38. Carruthers, Winning Hearts and Minds, 199. 39. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 92. 40. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 94–5. 41. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 98. 42. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 106. 43. R.S. Brazier, Memoir, 44–5, Brazier Papers, 07/43/1, IWM. 44. P.J. Houghton-Brown, Memoir, Part Four [1], Houghton-Brown Papers, 06/110/1, IWM. 45. I.W.G. Martin, Memoir, ‘In the Service of Queen and Country’, 5, Martin Papers, 91/32/1, IWM. 46. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 74. 47. Maj. C.R. Butt, Memoirs, 42, Butt Papers, 86/85/1, IWM. 48. The Daily Telegraph (8 January 1958), 13, quoted in Carruthers, Winning Hearts and Minds, 256. 49. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 70. 50. CitationPaget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 122. 51. CitationCharters, ‘From Palestine to Northern Ireland’, 199. 52. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 124, 184. 53. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 26. 54. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency, 1919–60, 137–8. 55. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 123. 56. Times of Cyprus (11 March 1957), quoted in CitationFoley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 123. 57. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, vii, 19. 58. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency, 1919–60, 137. 59. CitationAnderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’, 195. 60. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 97. 61. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 71. 62. Godfrey, The History of the Suffolk Regiment, 140–1, 147. 63. CitationCooper-Key, ‘Some Reflections on Cyprus’, 41–2. 64. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 171. 65. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 171–2; Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 98–9. 66. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 152–7; Newsinger, Ibid., 99. 67. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 76. 68. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 101–2. 69. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 77. 70. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 102. 71. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 77. 72. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars 73. Anderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’, 209. 74. CitationBaker, Grivas: Portrait of a Terrorist, 151. 75. Beckett, Citation Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies , 156. 76. Beckett, Citation Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies , 155–6. 77. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 99–100. 78. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 75. 79. Times of Cyprus (11 March 1957), quoted in Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 123; Nolan, Military Leadership and Counterinsurgency, 184–5. 80. Jeffery, ‘Intelligence and Counter-Insurgency Operations’, 129. 81. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 113. 82. Times of Cyprus (11 March 1957), quoted in Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 123. 83. Purdon, List the Bugle, 114. 84. Purdon, List the Bugle, 115. 85. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 150. 86. Sub-Editorial, The Iron Duke 33, no. 104 (April 1957), 37, quoted in Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 171. 87. ‘The Sarandi Hide’, The Iron Duke 33, no. 104 (April 1957), 44–6, quoted in Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 171–2. 88. CitationGrivas, Guerrilla Warfare and EOKA's Struggle, 52. 89. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 123. 90. Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 156. 91. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 150. 92. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 171. 93. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960 94. Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 156. 95. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 113–14. 96. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus; Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 173; Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 100. 97. CitationBlaxland, The Regiments Depart, 312; CitationCavenagh, Airborne to Suez, 79. 98. Grivas, Guerrilla Warfare and EOKA's Struggle, 51. 99. Grob-Fitzgibbon, Imperial Endgame, 297; CitationHolland, Britain and the Revolt in Cyprus, 56; Nolan, Military Leadership and Counterinsurgency, 172. 100. Gen. Sir Kenneth Darling, Cyprus the Final Round, October 1958–March 1959, 3, dated Apr. 1979, Darling Papers, File 5, 05/41/1, IWM. 101. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 124, 184. 102. Charters, ‘From Palestine to Northern Ireland’, 199. 103. Anderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’, 208–9; Young, Four Five, 226. 104. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 26. 105. Cavenagh, Airborne to Suez, 72. 106. Godfrey, The History of the Suffolk Regiment, 147–8, 152. 107. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 140. 108. Jeffery, ‘Intelligence and Counter-Insurgency Operations’, 125. 109. Anderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’, 209. 110. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency, 1919–60, 137. 111. Cavenagh, Airborne to Suez, 79. 112. Anderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’, 209. 113. Anderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’ 114. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency 1919–1960, 135–6, 188–9; CitationFrench, The British Way in Counter-Insurgency, 113–14, 145–7. 115. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 123–4. 116. Foley, Island in Revolt, 131. 117. Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 124. 118. CitationNeillands, A Fighting Retreat, 288. 119. Foley, Island in Revolt, 131. 120. Foley, Island in Revolt 121. Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 156; Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 78–9; Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 105. 122. Carruthers, Winning Hearts and Minds, 201. 123. Hoffman and Taw, Defense Policy and Low-Intensity Conflict, 29–30. 124. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 70–1. 125. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 145. 126. Benest, ‘Aden to Northern Ireland 1966–76’, 118–19. 127. I.W.G. Martin, Memoir: The Cyprus Troubles, 1955–1960, 25–26, Martin Papers, 91/32/1, IWM. 128. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency, 1919–60, 135. 129. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 146. 130. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 95–6. 131. Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 70–1. 132. Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 155; CitationNolan, Military Leadership and Counterinsurgency, 181–2. 133. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 145–6. 134. French, The British Way in Counter-Insurgency, 1945–1967, 113–14. 135. Maj. C.R. Butt, Memoirs, 42, Butt Papers, 86/85/1, IWM. 136. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 95. 137. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency, 1919–60, 136. 138. Brig. G.H. Baker, The Cyprus Emergency (Baker Report), 41–2, MSS.Medit.s.28, British Library of Commonwealth and African Studies [BLCAS] Rhodes House, Oxford. 139. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 98. 140. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 100. 141. Carruthers, Winning Hearts and Minds, 200. 142. Mockaitis, British Counterinsurgency, 1919–60, 110. 143. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 95. 144. Paget, Counter-Insurgency Campaigning, 146. 145. I.W.G. Martin, Extracts from Letters from Cyprus, June–August 1958, 4–5, 8 July 1958, Martin Papers, 91/32/1, IWM. 146. I.W.G. Martin, Extracts from Letters from Cyprus, June–August 1958, 4–5, 8 July 1958, Martin Papers, 91/32/1, IWM, 6, 24, 31 July 1958. 147. CitationDurrell, Bitter Lemons, 183, 242, quoted in Carruthers, Winning Hearts and Minds, 200. 148. CitationDurrell, Bitter Lemons 149. The Observer (24 November 1958), quoted in Foley and Scobie, The Struggle for Cyprus, 150. 150. Brig. G.H. Baker, Cyprus Emergency (Baker Report), 75–6, MSS.Medit.s.28, BLCAS. 151. Young, Four Five, 227–9. 152. I.W.G. Martin, Memoir: The Cyprus Troubles, 1955–1960, 18–19, Martin Papers, 91/32/1. 153. CitationFoley, Island in Revolt, 202; Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 105. 154. Maj. C.R. Butt, Memoirs, 24, Butt Papers, 86/85/1, IWM. 155. CitationPurcell, Cyprus, 249; French, The British Way in Counter-Insurgency, 155. 156. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 106–7; Dewar, Brush Fire Wars, 79–80. 157. Mrs J.M. Somerville, Diary, 3 Oct. 1958, Somerville Papers, 93/30/1, IWM. 158. Anonymous letter to I.W.G. Martin, Extracts from Letters from Cyprus, June–August 1958, 7, 5 August 1958, Martin Papers, 91/32/1, IWM. 159. French, The British Way in Counter-Insurgency, 146. 160. Charters, ‘From Palestine to Northern Ireland’, 189. 161. Charters, ‘From Palestine to Northern Ireland’, 190. 162. Newsinger, British Counterinsurgency, 106–7. 163. Benest, ‘Aden to Northern Ireland 1966–76’, 120. 164. Beckett, Modern Insurgencies and Counter-Insurgencies, 156. 165. CitationBowyer Bell, ‘Revolts Against the Crown’, 31–46. 166. Benest, ‘Aden to Northern Ireland 1966–76’, 120. 167. CitationKitson, Bunch of Five, 211. 168. Anderson, ‘Policing and Communal Conflict’, 211.