Canadian Journal of Philosophy · 2013 · 44 citations · 40 references
HumanitiesPhilosophyKnowledge RepresentationPhilosophy Of LanguageSemanticsConstituent PowerConstituent Structure
In this paper, I criticize Structured Propositionalism, the most widely held theory of the nature of propositions according to which they are structured entities with constituents. I argue that the proponents of Structured Propositionalism have paid insufficient attention to the metaphysical presuppositions of the view – most egregiously, to the notion of propositional constituency. This is somewhat ironic, since the friends of structured propositions tend to argue as if the appeal to constituency gives their view a dialectical advantage. I criticize four different approaches to providing a metaphysics of propositional constituency: set-theoretic, mereological, hylomorphic, and structure-making. Finally, I consider the option of taking constituency in a deflationary, metaphysically ‘lightweight’ sense. I argue that, though invoking constituency in a lightweight sense may be useful for avoiding the ontological problems that plague the ‘heavyweight’ conception, it no longer proffers a dialectical advantage to Structured Propositionalism.
40
The Principles of Mathematics.
E. N., Bertrand Russell · The Journal of Philosophy · 1938 · 1.9K citations
Humanities, Mathematics, Philosophy +10
David Lewis · The Philosophical Review · 1979 · 1.9K citations
R. W. H. T. H. · Nature · 1903 · 1.9K citations · Full text
Paul Benacerraf · The Philosophical Review · 1965 · 1.1K citations