On the onset of high-Reynolds-number grid-generated wind tunnel turbulence

Laurent Mydlarski, Z. Warhaft

Journal of Fluid Mechanics · 1996 · 458 citations · 35 references

Concepts

Abstract

Using an active grid devised by Makita (1991), shearless decaying turbulence is studied for the Taylor-microscale Reynolds number, R λ , varying from 50 to 473 in a small (40 × 40 cm 2 cross-section) wind tunnel. The turbulence generator consists of grid bars with triangular wings that rotate and flap in a random way. The value of R λ is determined by the mean speed of the air (varied from 3 to 14 m s –1 ) as it passes the rotating grid, and to a lesser extent by the randomness and rotation rate of the grid bars. Our main findings are as follows. A weak, not particularly well-defined scaling range (i.e. a power-law dependence of both the longitudinal ( u ) and transverse ( v ) spectra, F 11 ( k 1 ) and F 22 ( k 1 ) respectively, on wavenumber k 1 ) first appears at R λ ∼ 50, with a slope, n 1 , (for the u spectrum) of approximately 1.3. As R λ was increased, n 1 increased rapidly until R λ ∼ 200 where n ∼ 1.5. From there on the increase in n 1 was slow, and even by R λ = 473 it was still significantly below the Kolmogorov value of 1.67. Over the entire range, 50 [les ] R λ [les ] 473, the data were well described by the empirical fit: $n_1 = \frac{5}{3}(1-3.15R_\lambda^{-2/3})$ . Using a modified form of the Kolmogorov similarity law: F 11 ( k 1 ) = C 1* ε 2/3 k 1 –5/3 ( k 1 η) 5/3–n 1 where ε is the turbulence energy dissipation rate and η is the Kolmogorov microscale, we determined a linear dependence between n 1 and C 1* : C 1* = 4.5 – 2.4 n 1 . Thus for n 1 = 5/3 (which extrapolation of our results suggests will occur in this flow for R λ ∼ 10 4 ), C 1* = 0.5, the accepted high-Reynolds-number value of the Kolmogorov constant. Analysis of the p.d.f. of velocity differences Δ u(r) and Δ v(r) where r is an inertial subrange interval, conditional dissipation, and other statistics showed that there was a qualitative difference between the turbulence for R λ < 100 (which we call weak turbulence) and that for R λ > 200 (strong turbulence). For the latter, the p.d.f.s of Δ u(r) and Δ v(r) had super Gaussian tails and the dissipation (both of the u and v components) conditioned on Δ u(r) and Δ v(r) was a strong function of the velocity difference. For R λ < 100, p.d.f.s of Δ u(r) and Δ v(r) were Gaussian and conditional dissipation statistics were weak. Our results for R λ > 200 are consistent with the predictions of the Kolmogorov refined similarity hypothesis (and make a distinction between the dynamical and kinematical contributions to the conditional statistics). They have much in common with similar statistics done in shear flows at much higher R λ , with which they are compared.

References

35