It's the Thought That Counts

Rebecca Saxe, Lindsey J. Powell

Psychological Science · 2006 · 815 citations · 27 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Evidence from developmental psychology indicates that representing others' thoughts relies on a theory‑of‑mind component distinct from earlier mental‑state concepts. The study aimed to investigate the neural substrate of the late‑developing component of theory of mind in adult brains. The authors examined brain activity in adults while they read about others' thoughts to identify relevant neural regions. Functional MRI revealed that the right and left temporo-parietal junction and posterior cingulate selectively responded to others' thoughts, whereas the medial prefrontal cortex responded similarly across all social conditions, supporting distinct neural mechanisms for early and late theory of mind components into adulthood.

Abstract

Evidence from developmental psychology suggests that representing the contents of other people's thoughts and beliefs depends on a component of reasoning about other minds (theory of mind) that is distinct from the earlier-developing mental-state concepts for goals, perceptions, and feelings. To provide converging evidence, the current study investigated the substrate of the late-developing process in adult brains. Three regions—the right and left temporo-parietal junction and the posterior cingulate—responded selectively when subjects read about a protagonist's thoughts, but not when they read about other subjective, internal states or other socially relevant information about a person. By contrast, the medial prefrontal cortex responded equivalently in all of these story conditions, a result consistent with a broader role for medial prefrontal cortex in general social cognition. These data support the hypothesis that the early- and late-developing components of theory of mind rely on separate psychological and neural mechanisms, and that these mechanisms remain distinct into adulthood.

References

27