Evaluation of the performance of hysterosalpingo contrast sonography in 500 consecutive, unselected, infertile women

Abstract

The performance of hysterosalpingo contrast sonography (Hy Co Sy) as a first-line, outpatient investigation of tubal patency was examined in 500 consecutive, infertile women, at one centre. Hy Co Sy was completed in 463 (92.6%) cases, using a galactose microbubble contrast agent (Echovist-200) and transvaginal sonography. Initial plain scanning identified adnexal pathology in 198 women (39.6%). Examination with Echovist was attempted for 905 tubes and only 67 (7.4%) were not assessable; after the first 100 women this decreased to 35 tubes (4.8%). A sonographic appearance compatible with blocked tubes was found on 118 (14.1%) occasions but it was also possible to identify variations in the appearance/filling/spilling patterns of individual tubes which increased the number assessed as abnormal to 193 (23.0%). Comparison with laparoscopy and dye chromopertubation findings from the past three years was possible for 185 (37%) women, representing 282 tubes, which gave Hy Co Sy an overall concordance rate of 85.8%, sensitivity of 90.4%, specificity of 70.3%, positive predictive value of 91.2% and negative predictive value of 68.2%. Some 51.0% of women described only mild discomfort and there were no significant postprocedure complications. Hy Co Sy appears to be an acceptable first-line screen and may select out women in whom more invasive investigations are likely to reveal pathology.