Diet quality and prey selectivity correlate with life histories and predation regime in Trinidadian guppies

Abstract

1. Life histories evolve as a response to multiple agents of selection, such as age-specific mortality, resource availability or environmental fluctuations. Predators can affect life-history evolution directly, by increasing the mortality of prey, and indirectly, by modifying prey density and resources available to the survivors. Increasing survivor densities can intensify intraspecific competition and cause evolutionary changes in their selectivity, also affecting nutrient acquisition. 2. Here, we show that different life-history traits in guppies (Poecilia reticulata) are correlated with differences in resource consumption and prey selectivity. We examined differences in wild-caught guppy diet among stream types with high (HP) and low predation (LP) pressure and how they are related to benthic invertebrate biomass. Fish and invertebrate samples were collected from two HP and two LP reaches of two distinct study rivers in Trinidad. 3. Our results reveal a strong association between life history and diet. Guppies from HP environments mature earlier and have higher fecundity and reproductive allotment than those from LP environments. Prior work revealed that their population densities are lower and that they grow faster than their LP counterparts. Here, we show that these life-history differences are repeated and that HP guppies feed primarily on invertebrates. In contrast, guppies from LP sites feed primarily on detritus and algae, which are a poorer quality food. LP guppies fed on invertebrates according to their availability, while HP guppies were selective towards those invertebrates with the lower carbon/nitrogen body ratio and thus with higher nutritional value. 4. Our study suggests that as predators shape the life histories of their prey and alter prey population densities, they can also indirectly shape their prey’s foraging and diet selectivity. This is, to our knowledge, the first report on how intraspecific differences in life-history traits are correlated with prey selectivity, where prey stoichiometry is included. Although there are clear limitations of association data, our study suggests that the patterns of resource use and life history evolve in concert with one another. However, further research is needed to investigate the possible causal links between risk of predation, the indirect effects of predators on guppy population density, the evolution of life-history traits and nutrient acquisition.