Dentomaxillofacial Radiology · 2005 · 98 citations · 17 references
DentistryOral RadiologyTemporomandibular DisordersDental RadiologyMaxillofacial ImagingTemporomandibular Disorder EpidemiologyImaging AssessmentOcclusal EvaluationPrevalence Of Temporomandibular DisordersTemporomandibular Joint AnatomyTemporomandibular Joint ImagingTemporomandibular Joint RadiographyCondylar AnatomyInter-rater AgreementInter-rater ReliabilityInter-rater Reliability AssessmentMandibular Condylar MorphologyPanoramic ImagingPanoramic Radiography AssessmentPanoramic Radiography Interpretation
The study used panoramic radiographs to assess the reliability of TMJ condylar morphology evaluation and to compare condylar shape and abnormality prevalence between TMD patients and matched controls. Panoramic images were cropped to the TMJ region and independently evaluated by three blinded examiners, with statistical analyses applied to assess reliability. No morphological differences were found between TMD and control groups; mild condylar changes were common across all ages and were not predictive of TMD, indicating that condylar shape alone is not a useful indicator.
Panoramic radiography was used to determine (1) intrarater and inter-rater reliability in assessing temporomandibular joint (TMJ) condylar morphology; (2) alteration in condylar shape in patients with temporomandibular disorders (TMD) and controls when matched by age, gender, and state of dentition; and (3) prevalence of condylar abnormalities in individuals with and without TMD.One hundred panoramic radiographs were randomly selected from a hospital clinic (45 TMD and 55 non-TMD patients). The images were cropped to include only the temporomandibular apparatus and were independently evaluated by three examiners without knowledge of the patient's clinical status. Multiple statistical tests were performed to evaluate the accumulated data.Intrarater reliability demonstrated substantial agreement, while inter-rater reliability was fair. There was no difference in condylar morphology between patient groups, but mild condylar change was prevalent in all age groups, regardless of TMD status.Morphological condylar abnormalities are present on panoramic images in all adult age ranges, regardless of status of the dentition or presence of TMD. Condylar shape alone is not an indicator of TMD, and minor condylar discrepancies may have no significance in TMD.
17
The Measurement of Observer Agreement for Categorical Data
J. Richard Landis, Gary G. Koch · Biometrics · 1977 · 78.9K citations · Full text
Joel B. Epstein, John Caldwell, Gordon Black · Oral Surgery Oral Medicine Oral Pathology Oral Radiology and Endodontology · 2001 · 81 citations