Literature searching for social science systematic reviews: consideration of a range of search techniques

Diana Papaioannou, Anthea Sutton, Christopher Carroll, Andrew Booth, Ruth Wong

Health Information & Libraries Journal · 2009 · 319 citations · 14 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Literature on e‑learning student experience spans multiple disciplines, including health, education, social science, and library science. The study aimed to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of various search techniques for retrieving social science evidence. Researchers first performed a conventional subject search and then applied four supplementary methods—citation searching, reference list checking, expert contact, and pearl growing—to locate additional literature. The subject search yielded 30 of 41 included studies, but citation searching, reference list checking, and expert contact uncovered 11 more high‑quality references, demonstrating that while subject searching captures most evidence, supplementary techniques are essential for comprehensive coverage.

Abstract

Abstract Background: Literature for a systematic review on the student experience of e‐learning is located across a range of subject areas including health, education, social science, library and information science. Objectives: To assess the merits and shortcomings of using different search techniques in retrieval of evidence in the social science literature. Methods: A conventional subject search was undertaken as the principal method of identifying the literature for the review. Four supplementary search methods were used including citation searching, reference list checking, contact with experts and pearl growing. Results: The conventional subject search identified 30 of 41 included references; retrieved from 10 different databases. References were missed by this method and a further 11 references were identified via citation searching, reference list checking and contact with experts. Pearl growing was suspended as the nominated pearls were dispersed across numerous databases, with no single database indexing more than four pearls. Conclusions: Searching within the social sciences literature requires careful consideration. Conventional subject searching identified the majority of references, but additional search techniques were essential and located further high quality references.

References

14