Analysis of Work-of-Fracture Method for Measuring Fracture Energy of Concrete

Abstract

The role that plastic-frictional energy dissipation in the fracture process zone plays in the work-of-fracture method for measuring the fracture energy of concrete or other quasibrittle materials is analyzed, and a possible improvement of this method is proposed. It is shown that by measuring the unloading compliance at a sufficient number of states on the post-peak descending load-deflection curve, it is possible to calculate the pure fracture energy, representing the energy dissipated by the fracture process alone. However, this value of fracture energy is pertinent only if the material model (constitutive law and fracture law) used in structural analysis takes into account separately the fracture-damage deformations and the plastic-frictional deformations. Otherwise, one must use the conventional fracture energy, which includes plastic-frictional energy dissipation. Either type of fracture energy should properly be determined by extrapolation to infinite specimen size. Further, it is shown that the unloading compliancies to be used in the calculation of the pure fracture energy can be corrected to approximately eliminate the time-dependent effects (material viscoelasticity) and reverse plasticity. Finally, it is proposed to improve the work-of-fracture method by averaging the work done by fracture over only a central portion of the ligament. However, experiments are needed to check whether the specimen size required for this improved method would not be impracticably large.