Human Reproduction · 2008 · 73 citations · 12 references
Veterinary MedicineDevelopmental BiologyAssisted Reproductive TechnologiesEmbryo TransferEmbryologyEmbryo EvaluationEmbryo GradingEmbryo Quality GradingEmbryo SelectionEmbryo Transfer TechniquesPreimplantation Embryo DevelopmentEmbryo Assessment CriteriaEmbryo Genome ActivationEmbryo Morphology Scoring SystemsEmbryo Quality ScoringEmbryo Scoring AlgorithmsEmbryo Transfer Outcome AssessmentMorphological Embryo GradingSingle Embryo Transfer Selection
BACKGROUND: Single embryo transfers (SETs) require the most viable embryo from a cohort to be selected. Day 4 embryos may provide a selection advantage similar to blastocyst transfer as embryos are replaced post-embryonic genome activation and into the uterus where they would normally reside. However, there is currently no adequate morphological system to assess Day 4 embryos. Therefore, we developed an assessment system for Day 4 embryos and retrospectively assessed Day 4 SET success rates compared with Day 5 SETs. METHODS: Embryos (n = 996 after IVF or ICSI) were assessed on Day 4 of development, prior to implementing Day 4 embryo transfers, to obtain a descriptive range of embryo morphologies observed at this time point. A morphological scoring system was developed from this. All patients having an SET after extended culture (Day 4, n = 124 or Day 5, n = 193), at Repromed, Adelaide, Australia, during June 2006-January 2007 were analysed for pregnancy outcome. Ongoing pregnancy was determined by fetal cardiac activity at 6-8 weeks after oocyte collection. RESULTS: Day 4 and 5 SETs resulted in similar ongoing pregnancy rates of 38.7% and 32.1%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: A Day 4 scoring system was successfully developed and implemented. Day 4 SETs were found to be a viable option or alternative to Day 5 SETs with no difference in pregnancy rates.
12