'Being' Versus 'Doing' Punk: On Achieving Authenticity as a Member

Sue Widdicombe, Rob Wooffitt

Journal of Language and Social Psychology · 1990 · 125 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study investigates how members of punk, goth, and hippie subcultures use social comparisons in language to construct authenticity for themselves and their group, highlighting a device that frames membership motivations. The authors conducted informal interviews with punks, gothics, and hippies and analyzed three comparison types—external standards, temporal shifts within the subculture, and generational differences—to examine authenticity claims. Findings suggest that authenticity is achieved by emphasizing the distinction between “being” a member—having legitimate grounds for affiliation—and “doing” the performative aspects of the subculture, offering insights for social identity theory.

Abstract

In this paper we examine some ways in which members of subcultures make comparisons between and within subcultural groups and one function served by such comparisons. Specifically, we illustrate how social comparisons are used to achieve authenticity for the subcultural group and for the self as a member of that group. Our analysis focuses on the language through which such comparisons are made in people's talk. The data come from a series of informal interviews with punks, gothics and hippies. We analyse three types of comparison: the comparison of one or more groups with an external standard; the comparison of the subculture's past and present character; and the comparison between older and newer members. The implications of our findings for social identity theory are considered. Finally, we discuss an interesting and recurrent device for emphasising authenticity which lay in the construction of the descriptions of members' motivations for joining. This was related to the distinction between 'being' a member, or having the correct grounds for affiliation, and merely 'doing' or performing, aspects of the subculture.

References

29