Occidental Petroleum v Ecuador (2012): Observations on Proportionality, Assessment of Damages and Contributory Fault

Borzu Sabahi, K. K. Duggal

ICSID Review - Foreign Investment Law Journal · 2013 · 12 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

On 5 October 2012, the Tribunal in Occidental Petroleum Corporation and Occidental Exploration and Production Company (‘Occidental’ or ‘Claimants’) v Republic of Ecuador issued an Award granting the largest amount of damages to date in an investment treaty arbitration for approximately US$1.76 billion (plus interest) under the USA–Ecuador bilateral investment treaty (BIT), using a discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis.4 As expected, the case attracted much attention, and commentators and interest groups are divided in opinions on the case.5 Ecuador filed a motion for annulment of the Award within a week of its issuance.6 The Award, together with the dissenting opinion, is close to 400 pages. This comment only addresses four salient findings of the Award in light of broader principles of international law. These are the proportionality analysis and three points that have a significant bearing on the final amount awarded: the impact of Law 42 on the assessment of damages; Occidental’s standing to seek damages for the loss of 100 percent participation rights; and, finally, the notion of contributory fault and its impact on damages.