Organization · 2003 · 810 citations · 74 references
ManagementOrganization StudiesOrganizational BehaviorCritical TheoryOrganizational CultureSelfCorporate CultureCultural ResistanceOrganizational IdentityPower Distance In OrganizationsPower In OrganizationsDominant IdeologyOrganizational Resistance
Subjectivity and power shape corporate culture engineering, yet workers may either identify with or resist through cynicism, which is viewed as a defect by managerialist literature and as a defense mechanism by radical humanists. The authors propose a third perspective that sees cynicism as a process of dis-identification that still performs cultural prescriptions, and argue that this reframes power, subjectivity, and resistance in organizational studies. They label this view the ideology interpretation, noting that dis-identifying with power simultaneously reproduces it. Cynical employees feel autonomous yet continue to enact corporate rituals, suggesting that cultural power operates through dis-identification, subjectivity is external, and what counts as disruptive resistance must be reassessed.
Subjectivity and power are important concepts for understanding corporate culture engineering in critical organization studies. Although recent research indicates that many workers do identify with the organization as a result of these management strategies, they have also shown that some workers resist through dis-identification, in particular cynicism. Managerialist literature views cynicism as a psychological defect that needs to be `corrected', while a radical humanist approach constructs cynicism as a defence mechanism, a way of blocking the colonization of a pre-given self. We highlight a third and increasingly dominant perspective that suggests cynicism is a process through which employees dis-identify with cultural prescriptions, yet often still perform them. Cynical employees have the impression that they are autonomous, but they still practice the corporate rituals nonetheless. We label this the `ideology' interpretation because in dis-identifying with power, it is inadvertently reproduced at the same time. We argue that this approach to cynicism raises significant implications for key concepts in organization studies: those of power, subjectivity and resistance. The implications we pursue are that cultural power may work through dis-identification (rather than just identification), subjectivity may be radically `external' (rather than something `within') and thus what counts as disruptive resistance must be re-evaluated.
74
Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity
Mary McIntosh, Judith Butler · Feminist Review · 1991 · 28.1K citations
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison
Roberto D’Amico · Telos · 1978 · 19.6K citations
Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison.
David W. Tarbet, Alan Sheridan · Eighteenth-Century Studies · 1978 · 19.3K citations
Organizational culture and leadership
Long Range Planning · 1993 · 16.6K citations