Discourse & Society · 2004 · 166 citations · 10 references
Social SciencesBiotechnologyCommunicationDiscourse AnalysisRhetoricScience CommunicationPublic DiscoursePublic Engagement With SciencePublic Perceptions Of SciencePublic Understanding Of ScienceRegulatory Frameworks For Transgenic CropsRhetoric Of ScienceCommunication Of Scientific ControversyEquivalence Of Genetic ModificationPublic Dialogue About SciencePublic Engagement In BiotechnologyPublic Understanding Of AgriculturePublic Understanding Of BiotechnologyPublic Understanding Of GeneticsUse Of Experts
Debates about new technologies, such as crop and food genetic modification (GM), raise pressing questions about the ways ‘experts’ and ‘ nonexperts’ communicate. These debates are dynamic, characterized by many voices contesting numerous storylines. The discoursal features, including language choices and communication strategies, of the GM debate are in some ways taken for granted and in others actively manipulated by participants. Although there are many voices, some have more influence than others. This study makes use of 50 hours of in-depth interviews with GM scientists, nonexperts, and other stakeholders in the GM debate to examine this phenomenon. We uncover rhetorical devices used by scientists to characterize and ultimately undermine participation by non-experts in areas including rationality, knowledge, understanding and objectivity. Scientists engage with ‘the public’ from their own linguistic and social domain, without reflexive confirmation of their own status as part of the public and the citizenry. This raises a number of interesting ironies and contradictions, which are explored in the article. As such, it provides valuable insights into an increasingly important type of discourse.
10
Choice Reviews Online · 1990 · 19.5K citations
Creating Public Alienation: Expert Cultures of Risk and Ethics on GMOs
Brian Wynne · Science as Culture · 2001 · 563 citations · Full text
Humanities, Cultures, Bioethics +4
Europeans and Biotechnology in 2002
George Gaskell, Nick Allum, Sally Stares et al. · 2003 · 224 citations
Europe ambivalent on biotechnology
MW Bauer, Joël M. Durant, George Gaskell et al. · Nature · 1997 · 188 citations · Full text