Living in several languages: Language, gender and identities

Charlotte Burck

European Journal of Women s Studies · 2011 · 25 citations · 32 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Living in multiple languages involves constructing distinct selves within each linguistic context. The study adopts an intersectional perspective to explore how multilingual speakers shape self, family relationships, and broader social contexts. Researchers analyzed 24 interviews and five autobiographies using grounded theory, narrative, and discursive methods, noting that negotiating linguistic and cultural differences requires reflective and discursive work. Participants found that learning a new language exposed them to gendered discourses and power dynamics while also fostering creativity and new self‑perceptions, and they used language differences to perform gender, particularly in family settings, and the authors contend that the notion of “mother tongue” is unhelpful for understanding these dynamics.

Abstract

Living in several languages encompasses experiencing and constructing oneself differently in each language. The research study on which this article is based takes an intersectional approach to explore insider accounts of the place of language speaking in individuals’ constructions of self, family relationships and the wider context. Twenty-four research interviews and five published autobiographies were analysed using grounded theory, narrative and discursive analysis. A major finding was that learning a new language inducted individuals into somewhat ‘stereotyped’ gendered discourses and power relations within the new language, while also enabling them to view themselves differently in the context of their first language. This embodied process could be challenging and often required reflection and discursive work to negotiate the dissimilarities, discontinuities and contradictions between languages and cultures. However, the participants generally claimed that their linguistic multiplicity generated creativity. Women and men used their language differences differently to ‘perform their gender’. This was particularly evident in language use within families, which involved gendered differences in the choice of language for parenting – despite the fact that both men and women experience their first languages as conveying intimacy in their relationships with their children. The article argues that the notion of ‘mother tongue’ (rather than ‘first language’) is unhelpful in this process as well as in considering the implications of living in several languages for systemic therapy.

References

32