Intercomparison of Bulk Aerodynamic Algorithms for the Computation of Sea Surface Fluxes Using TOGA COARE and TAO Data

Xubin Zeng, Ming Zhao, Robert E. Dickinson

Journal of Climate · 1998 · 748 citations · 26 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study builds on TOGA COARE data to derive roughness lengths for wind, humidity, and temperature across 0–18 m s⁻¹, providing a basis for bulk aerodynamic flux calculations. The authors develop a bulk aerodynamic algorithm applicable to all stability conditions for computing ocean surface fluxes. Using the derived roughness‑length formulas, the algorithm is applied to TOGA COARE ship data and multiyear buoy observations to intercompare six widely used flux algorithms across a range of wind speeds. The intercomparison reveals that algorithms differ markedly in heat and momentum fluxes under very weak and very strong winds but agree under moderate winds, with wind stress estimates showing better consistency than heat fluxes, deficiencies in roughness‑length parameterizations identified, and a 2 % vapor‑pressure reduction over saline water significantly affecting latent heat flux calculations.

Abstract

A bulk aerodynamic algorithm is developed for all stability conditions for the computation of ocean surface fluxes. It provides roughness lengths of wind, humidity, and temperature for a wind speed range from 0 to 18 m s−1: zo = 0.013u2∗/g + 0.11ν/u∗ and ln(zo/zot) = ln(zo/zoq) = 2.67Re1/4∗ − 2.57 as derived using the Tropical Oceans Global Atmosphere (TOGA) Coupled Ocean–Atmosphere Response Experiment (COARE) data constrained by other observations under high wind conditions. Using the TOGA COARE ship data and the multiyear hourly TOGA Tropical Atmosphere–Ocean moored buoy data, intercomparison of six different algorithms, which are widely used in research, operational forecasting, and data reanalysis, shows that algorithms differ significantly in heat and momentum fluxes under both very weak and very strong wind conditions, but agree with each other under moderate wind conditions. Algorithms agree better for wind stress than for heat fluxes. Based on past observations, probable deficiencies in roughness lengths (or neutral exchange coefficients) of some of the algorithms are identified along with possible solutions, and significant issues (particularly the trend of the neutral exchange coefficient for heat with wind speed under strong wind conditions) are raised for future experiments. The vapor pressure reduction of 2% over saline seawater has a significant impact on the computation of surface latent heat flux under strong wind conditions and should be considered in any bulk aerodynamic algorithm.

References

26