The New Judicial Politics of Legal Doctrine

Jeffrey R. Lax

Annual Review of Political Science · 2011 · 118 citations · 69 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The new judicial politics of legal doctrine aims to resolve foundational dilemmas and reconcile scholarly divisions by integrating legal concerns with political science priorities. The study investigates the intellectual origins and primary contributions of the approach, focusing on how collegiality and hierarchy shape legal policy. The approach employs a case‑space model—an adaptation of policy‑space modeling—that captures ideological differences among judges by partitioning fact‑filled cases into distinct legal dispositions.

Abstract

A new judicial politics of legal doctrine has the potential to resolve foundational dilemmas and reconcile long-standing and counterproductive scholarly divisions by bringing together legal concerns and political science priorities. This doctrinal-politics approach highlights a relatively new formal apparatus known as the case-space model, and it invokes close ties between theoretical and empirical work and between the study of judicial behavior and actual legal practices and institutions. The case-space model is an adaption of standard policy-space modeling, tailored for the distinguishing features of judicial policy making. It allows for ideological differences between judges while expressing those differences in terms of legal rules that partition fact-filled legal cases into different dispositions. I explore the intellectual origins and primary contributions of the approach, focusing on how legal policy is affected by collegiality (the multi-member nature of appellate courts) and hierarchy (the multi-level division of court systems).

References

69