Using a 3-D Virtual Sunflower to Simulate Light Capture at Organ, Plant and Plot Levels: Contribution of Organ Interception, Impact of Heliotropism and Analysis of Genotypic Differences

H. Rey, Jean Dauzat, Karine Chenu, Jean‐François Barczi, Guillermo A. A. Dosio

Annals of Botany · 2007 · 45 citations · 36 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Light interception is a critical factor in the production of biomass. The study presented here describes a method used to take account of architectural changes over time in sunflower and to estimate absorbed light at the organ level. The amount of photosynthetically active radiation absorbed by a plant is estimated on a daily or hourly basis through precise characterization of the light environment and three-dimensional virtual plants built using AMAP software. Several treatments are performed over four experiments and on two genotypes to test the model, quantify the contribution of different organs to light interception and evaluate the impact of heliotropism. This approach is used to simulate the amount of light absorbed at organ and plant scales from crop emergence to maturity. Blades and capitula were the major contributors to light interception, whereas that by petioles and stem was negligible. Light regimen simulations showed that heliotropism decreased the cumulated light intercepted at the plant scale by close to 2·2 % over one day. The approach is useful in characterizing the light environment of organs and the whole plant, especially for studies on heterogeneous canopies or for quantifying genotypic or environmental impacts on plant architecture, where conventional approaches are ineffective. This model paves the way to analyses of genotype–environment interactions and could help establish new selection criteria based on architectural improvement, enhancing plant light interception. Intercepted light is an important component for plant energy balance and plant biomass accumulation (Monteith, 1977; Jones, 1992). Higher plants display a high degree of plasticity in their morphological responses to light (e.g. Slade and Hutchings, 1987; Granier and Tardieu, 1999). These complex interactions between plants and their light environment make it difficult to estimate the amount of light intercepted at the plant scale. This problem may be circumnavigated by considering the canopy as a continuous medium. The amount of intercepted radiation can then be estimated by the Beer–Lambert law using the leaf area index (LAI) and an extinction coefficient, k, specific for the cover (e.g. Varlet-Grancher et al., 1989). This approach is appropriate for a developed canopy and has been extensively used in crop management to estimate light absorption by the canopy or organs. However, this classical approach is not designed to study heterogeneous or sparse canopies such as crops in the early stages of growth (Chenu et al., 2007b), orchards or vineyards (Louarn et al., 2007), rosette plants (Chenu et al., 2005), or isolated plants used in research trials which may be grown in pots. Furthermore, this classical approach cannot be used for artificial environments such as greenhouses or growth chambers (Chenu et al., 2005) where artificial lighting, walls and supporting structures make the incident radiation heterogeneous. Finally, this classical approach is not designed to analyse the impact of architectural changes over time, especially for short time steps such as heliotropism. An alternative approach is to consider the crop as a population of individual plants and calculate the light microclimate for individual plant organs. Over the past few decades, computer programs have been developed to model, simulate and display the three-dimensional (3-D) architecture of plants (e.g. Jaeger and de Reffye, 1992; Prusinkiewicz, 1998). 3-D virtual plants (Barczi et al., 2008) can be used to estimate plant–environment interactions (Chelle, 2005), for example in terms of radiative balance (e.g. Dauzat and Eroy, 1997; Chelle and Andrieu, 1998, 1999) or energy balance (Rapidel et al., 1999). The aim of the present study was to couple and adapt the AMAPsim architectural model (Barczi et al., 2008) and MMR radiative calculation software (Dauzat and Eroy, 1997; Dauzat et al., 2001, 2008) to simulate the amount of radiation absorbed by a 3-D virtual sunflower plant at organ, plant and plot scales over time, from plant emergence until maturity. Organ development and expansion were estimated over thermal time from fitting performed on measured data. This approach was tested in a field experiment on two genotypes of contrasted architectures. Simulations were also performed under a variety of environmental conditions, in the field and in greenhouses, with different densities, shading treatments, and isolated and/or decapitulated plants to analyse the effects of various plant architectures on light interception. The model developed was also used to quantify the contribution made by the different organs to light interception and the impact of heliotropism on the light intercepted by 3-D virtual plants. Greenhouse and field experiments were carried out to (1) parameterize the AMAPsim model used to simulate sunflower growth and architecture, (2) adapt the MMR model to greenhouse conditions and (3) test the AMAPsim and MMR combination in such situations. 3-D virtual plants were built on the basis of measurements made for each experiment × treatment combination. The light environment for each treatment was measured for use in MMR. A combination of these two models was used to simulate the light balance at organ level over time for plants of different architectures (different genotypes, light treatments, densities and decapitulated plants) Sunflower (Helianthus annuus L., hybrid ‘Albena’) plants were grown in Montpellier, southern France (43°40′N, 3°50′E), either in greenhouses (E–W orientation) or in the field during five experiments conducted in 1998, 1999 and 2001 (Table 1). Designs of the different experimental situations with the applied treatments Designs of the different experimental situations with the applied treatments In the greenhouse experiments, seeds were sown at a depth of 0·03 m in columns (0·14 m diameter and 0·65 m height) consisting of a 1: 1 mixture (v/v) of loamy soil and organic compost. Soil was maintained at water retention capacity by watering columns three times a day with a modified, one-tenth-strength Hoagland solution corrected with minor nutrients. Additional light was provided by a bank of sodium lamps, maintaining an average photoperiod of 14 h. In the field experiments, seeds were sown at a depth of 0·02 m in a deep sandy loam soil (fluvio-calcaric Cambissol) with 0·6 m between rows and 0·3 m between seeds in each row. Plants were grown in rows orientated N–S, with individual plots for each treatment ranging from 78 to 400 m2. Nitrogen fertilization was applied before sowing (80 kg ha−1). Soil water potential was monitored by means of tensiometers (DTE 1000 system, Nardeux, Saint-Avertin, France) and maintained by irrigation above –40 kPa in the top 0·5 m of soil, in a range for which neither stomatal conductance nor leaf growth was affected (Sadras and Milroy, 1996). Four treatments were applied and two genotypes tested (Table 1). The ‘control’ treatment (Gh-Feb98-1, Gh-Nov98-1, Fd-May99-1 and Fd-May-01-1) plants were not subject to any shading or architectural manipulations. The second treatment (Fd-May98-2, Fd-May99-2) corresponded to isolated plants obtained by thinning after seedling emergence to avoid light competition between neighbouring plants. In the third treatment (Fd-May-99-31 and Fd-May-99-32), the plants in two plots were subject to shading that intercepted 75 % of the incident photosynthetically active radiation (PAR). The first plot (Fd-May-99-31) was shaded between 220 and 420 °Cd after plant emergence, i.e. the period corresponding to leaf development on the lower part of the main stem. The second plot (Fd-May-99-32) was shaded between 420 and 580 °Cd, during leaf establishment on the middle of the main stem. In the fourth treatment (Gh-Feb98-4, Gh-Nov98-4 and Fd-May98-4), the plants were decapitulated on appearance of the bud flower in order to suppress the reproductive sink and prevent the growing capitulum from shading the upper leaves. Finally, two different hybrids (‘Albena’: Fd-May01-1A and ‘Heliasol’: Fd-May01-1H) were grown under control conditions to analyse the of their contrasted architectures. were measured in the middle of the photosynthetically active was measured above the canopy using a and were measured m above the soil using an in a was measured using time measurements for the different organs were measured during their development by means of five in the bud and on the of the of and on five plants used for measurements in each and leaf incident and were measured then and in a Over the plant emergence, daily from to for the different experimental daily leaf from to and daily cumulated incident from to incident over the plant was three times in field experiments in greenhouse experiments (Table of the different experimental situations with the environmental conditions and the of the average plant at for each experiment are estimated over plant emergence by an over the shading in are of the different experimental situations with the environmental conditions and the of the average plant at for each experiment are estimated over plant emergence by an over the shading in are light were measured in the field and greenhouse using a of or different and (Chenu et al., these measurements were not the experiments, a was developed to estimate light from incident light measured the greenhouse and artificial by light was measured during the using the and applied over the of The light the greenhouse was to the radiation through an extinction for light interception by greenhouse were at the of each experiment at soil level and 1 m on a 1 × The of intercepted was measured in field experiment on and using above and the In to plants were in each plot on the basis of stem diameter and plant for were from plants development and emergence was as the on which the first leaf in between i.e. °Cd after Four to plants were three times a from plant emergence to capitulum to in the This was under a and were The of in the bud were measured using a to an measurements were made three times from plant emergence to the time at which organs to after plant stem and and and and 1 were measured with a and on the plants. of on the and and were measured using a was to that was with on the and that area could be estimated from measurements of and A was in each experiment between the of × and measured were measured in the experiment over the using three in a 3-D The plant development was after of the capitulum was in the stem not and not through and and the cover not Organ were then and of petioles and by thermal time was by daily of leaf a basis of and Tardieu, 1998). thermal time was cumulated either from plant emergence thermal time, or from organ thermal time, a organ, the calculation was made using (1) from organ to emergence, (2) from organ emergence to the of and (3) leaf thermal time was as the average of the different organ were their growth from and as of architecture, and were used to a 3-D virtual sunflower using the AMAPsim (Barczi et al., The sunflower a that was by considering four main of the the the and the on the main stem by the were as the first steps in the were from the to the top from 1 to and were used to simulate growth of the stem (Barczi et al., 2008) to a and each a steps were from to on 1 to and from to on petioles to the top of the main the capitulum was using four organ the which also the the and the The for sunflower was then the of in growing were to for corresponded to a 3-D which was using a 3-D on the basis of organs. are and a was applied to these in and to the was with to take account of and the of of 3-D organ used to display 3-D virtual for main stem and petioles and example of a flower in the each a and two are The of these was diameter and to in order to calculation of for the of the 3-D virtual of their (e.g. at the or top of the and growth and organ expansion over plant thermal time were in the AMAPsim to the development and growth of each 3-D virtual plants were built from (1) the of the different in the and to in order to organ growth and and from (2) of for and Simulations were carried out from emergence to the of the growth as based on a daily time and for treatment × and organ growth and development were from an average plant, that plants in the canopy organs of the organ and were estimated from a of based on measurements performed on five plants by Plants in the canopy in terms of An was to AMAPsim to calculate in 3-D plants on an hourly basis using measurements in the field The et al., et al., 1992; et al., was used to the canopy by the plants in virtual plots in with the for each treatment × plants were 0·6 × 0·3 m with for the from plants grown in the a plot of was with a plot of for isolated plants. were orientated at were in by the MMR model such that radiative simulations were performed The light in the virtual plots was by the MMR the of three and model Dauzat and Eroy, 1997; Dauzat et al., for short The the to model 1989). The first the interception of light by and and soil from the of on from the of each The second the of intercepted light and the of and soil (Dauzat et al., These two a light balance for each of The third of in order to the light balance of the plot for the light conditions of the treatment first the and of incident radiation and then these the (Dauzat et al., Organ is obtained as the of by incident and light from each of light from canopy to organ that interception of light is to organ The study was conducted using 3-D virtual plants built with or to as and plants were as i.e. with petioles and in their average and capitulum were on an hourly basis for to plants showed a of and this for experiments and treatments (Table as et al., were also for plants under experimental conditions with of for the first four for the and for Plants at a and isolated plants grown a of 0·02 m on average whereas grown in the field at plants were with ranging from to from (Table diameter between the experimental treatments with for isolated plants or in plants grown at a leaf area was the architectural affected by the level of incident (Table The experiments conducted a range of incident to and of the conditions in sunflower leaf area for from to the capitulum a on leaf area and stem diameter in greenhouse was in isolated plants. area was the plants were subject to early shading from to the was not shading treatment 3-D virtual plants were for each experiment and treatment as daily steps over the first after plant emergence, the period of organ expansion were for plants grown under contrasted environmental conditions The cumulated absorbed by the plant over the emergence from of for greenhouse plants in the and for field plants at a to for isolated plants. The model was applied to the which a different leaf area the stem and a stem in upper A is as an example for the virtual plot of the of an 3-D virtual plant in Fd-May01-1A with a growth from to plant of 3-D virtual plants corresponding to an plant for each experimental for greenhouse plants in the first for isolated plants with and Fd-May99-2) or capitulum in the second and for and plants grown in canopy in the third row. are for 3-D plant of a virtual plot with 3-D virtual plants. for 3-D virtual plants were by fitting the measurements on organs three times between and a of and that changes in individual with thermal time were The of organ expansion and development and over time in an of the different at the level plant area or plant the crop development The of between and was in % of for the architectural (e.g. and and estimated by of of from to Simulations carried out with of the measurements measurements can be used to 3-D virtual plants. leaf area and over thermal time from plant emergence for and data. for area of leaves. for Light balance was by the of intercepted in virtual plots with the corresponding experimental measurements in the field The are presented for Fd-May01-1A and with the of intercepted as a either of thermal time or The of intercepted was with a of of and a of the that this was made at the canopy the of the model to account for between genotypes and between different situations the of this approach to complex interactions between light and plant in and of intercepted for a plot of plants and plants from emergence to after emergence from Fd-May01-1A and are as °Cd from plant emergence thermal time, A and or leaf area index and was performed at plant to test the at the organ level. The of intercepted was measured in canopy plants were such that the the petioles and capitulum The of intercepted by these plants was 0·3 and not from the The of absorbed at the plot scale showed a over thermal time emergence to °Cd, the of absorbed was then over the °Cd to a of °Cd for greenhouse and field plants in the canopy and °Cd for isolated plants were in the greenhouse and field canopy experiments and for isolated plants. However, it was difficult to the of absorbed at the between isolated and canopy plants as this on plot for isolated plants In the the of absorbed of the plot was as a of it until then in a to a of was in or the incident light The Beer–Lambert law was used for in plants the canopy was the Beer–Lambert law using light and on 3-D virtual plants an extinction of in and in under a of incident with 1 % the of absorbed by % as with a of with % the of radiative conditions on the of intercepted in the of absorbed by the different organs of 3-D virtual plants of a plot for after different organs as greenhouse plants in field canopy plants in and isolated plants in are in to either thermal time after plant emergence or leaf area index Simulations that before the capitulum developed on the absorption for % of for greenhouse and field plants in the canopy °Cd, absorption decreased to This corresponded to the in capitulum which at The capitulum intercepted a major of incident light during the reproductive and the light for the This was not in isolated which light plants in the absorption by and petioles was and for % of the absorption in the whole in plant light absorption decreased after °Cd to shading by plant organs. This contribution to light absorption the minor contribution made by these organs to plant and in leaf over thermal time showed in the different experimental situations An until °Cd was to the major in leaf area in whereas was negligible. This in to 400 °Cd as stem the from each the leaves. The then decreased as plant leaf area to until the of expansion stem The for corresponded to the of plant leaf The for this were different between the experiments and treatments, the of an architectural approach in such a in leaf for greenhouse experiments, field canopy treatments and isolated over after plant different experiments and and Fd-May01-1A and and are presented in to thermal time after plant the and of the stem and the as as and over the The time of the of is presented in for of a plant, as an of the of the with for orientated in the (e.g. and in in the (e.g. and at the of the stem to be in the The at the top (e.g. in were not and and their showed of the for of a plant in the Fd-May99-1 from to with a time of the of a leaf at a time, from an of The of the main stem is at the of the plot and leaf are presented on their from this over time, as by an for leaf These complex were in the model to evaluate their impact on light interception. absorption by plant organs was estimated on an hourly basis for 3-D virtual plants with or the time the was the capitulum growth and light interception was minor were for absorption by a day with with and these A in plants was at to an in shading the The daily absorbed by the was plant for plants and for plants. a 2·2 % in light on the light balance in Fd-May99-1 of average absorbed hourly by the of a plant or not for different organs as leaf over the day for plants with or with a Sunflower high interception with and this % in the The for interception was in the field at an of that sunflower canopies are light their % of the intercepted by is of this is by This in the canopy % of incident radiation These complex plant–environment interactions in terms of over time between the experiments and treatments light interception difficult to an architectural model with a light model to estimate the light the of the is one of a few and a model used to estimate crop light interception over time and at the organ level (e.g. et al., interception was here with field measurements over time for two and at the organ level in a specific experiment with simulations at the organ level the approach field measurements of organ are for a of in a few plants. The approach developed in this study could be used and responses by light terms of and and a specific field of is the of these responses for genotypes with contrasted architectures (Chenu et al., In leaf expansion is to the amount of light intercepted during the first of this expansion and Tardieu, et al., this during the first of the plant the plants are and the canopy is heterogeneous. The model developed here can be used to estimate the light intercepted during of crop and especially during stages the of the Beer–Lambert law are not The first stages of plant development have a major impact on plant establishment and such a model could also help the of which on the of light intercepted over this period (Chenu et al., have been developed over the to 3-D plants using either measurements using a 3-D et al., of organ and et al., et al., or the of plant growth and Prusinkiewicz, and Andrieu, 1998, et al., The method presented here can be used to simulate plant growth over time and was designed to with for leaf growth and development to light the time that 3-D virtual plant was light models were also to simulate light with 3-D virtual plants (e.g. and et al., 1998). these models can be used to radiation is between plant organs. These 3-D radiative models a of In radiation is to be the and Chelle and Andrieu, et al., whereas the of is for in MMR (Dauzat et al., and in et al., This was in MMR by the and considering each as a light This of light that the model was for greenhouse artificial environments is important in or for research experiments carried out in greenhouses or growth In such the and of incident light is to each on structures and the artificial the light specific to the environment is the absorbed may be for growing conditions (e.g. et al., in a growth The of models to simulate light is important of radiative and Andrieu, et al., et al., and et al., 2005) can be used to simulate light in plant the are In the present the canopy light balance was day the crop development period and this The MMR model was in this of the light is intercepted by the with stem and petioles % to light interception. However, the capitulum an important to plant light balance in growth % to absorption at This high level of light interception by the capitulum be account the energy and water of a sunflower canopy and plants in the by the capitulum decreased leaf by % and this to a in daily leaf However, may also to especially before the capitulum This to a the contribution made by capitulum organs to growth the capitulum et al., the amount of light absorbed by the capitulum the of this organ and development and in sunflower was to the light intercepted by the plant (e.g. by of the The present study not on heliotropism of the capitulum also on of the main stem and the leaves. heliotropism was for in expansion at the top of the the capitulum not The on light interception cannot be through field measurements plants cannot be in a an alternative as used were with in terms of light interception the day. The simulations showed that heliotropism has on the light balance over one day at the crop level. such conditions, the of absorbed daily time that the effects of heliotropism were also showed that and complex on an hourly basis are the light balance of a sunflower However, it is that effects in plant development may be Furthermore, in the of studies on individual leaf expansion or it may be to estimate the effects of heliotropism at the organ level as this may an in terms of light absorbed by the at on the stem. daily changes in the shading of and the between the and the leaf and the of on their heliotropism may plant by the contribution made by which are photosynthetically leaves. are to the of a radiation use in to the of and with an in radiation the of and may the high for sunflower in with plants and 1999). The model developed here could help to these Furthermore, the performed on absorbed could be to such as organ by an energy balance and then be to estimate such as (Rapidel et al., et al., The level and of 3-D virtual plant to studies of different The two hybrids showed a plant leaf absorbed light the impact of organ in light interception. The of sunflower have to the selection of with different architectures et al., hybrids intercepted light and architectural were to be et al., the way to sunflower through architectural In such a using the model to analyse the contribution of architectural in various genotypes be useful to new selection criteria to their in light interception. to and for and in and in in of daily environmental and to for of plant irrigation and for and and This is part of the by

References

36