Community ownership of physical assets: Challenges, complexities and implications

Sarah Skerratt, Clare Hall

Local Economy The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit · 2011 · 23 citations · 14 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Rural development policy increasingly promotes community ownership of physical assets, supported by Asset‑Based Community Development and Community Capitals models, but some stakeholders raise concerns about the hidden challenges and risks of this normative shift. This study reviews those concerns using new data from a totemic rural village hall. We surveyed 347 village hall committees and framed the results within an assets framework. The survey revealed that built assets can become liabilities, the financial base of village halls is weak, and human assets are vulnerable, underscoring the need to assess ownership complexities, evaluate community capacity, provide targeted support, and pursue long‑term investment rather than short‑term spending, thereby questioning the assumption that asset ownership alone drives sustainable economic development.

Abstract

Within rural development policy and practice there is increasing emphasis on asset ownership and management by communities, emphasizing empowerment, inclusion and securing of local futures. Asset-Based Community Development and Community Capitals models support this view. To the majority, this is part of an appropriate, normative shift towards realizing rights of place-based communities. A minority have concerns over the largely unspoken challenges and risks. We review these contentions within the context of new data relating to the totemic rural village hall. We conducted a survey of 347 village hall committees, and present our findings within an assets framework. We highlight complexities where: built assets may be liabilities; the financial asset-base of village halls is not robust; human assets are vulnerable in terms of succession and governance. Our findings show the need for: assessing complexities of asset ownership; evaluating community capacity for asset ownership; providing support where required; and longer-term investment rather than short-term spend. We thus qualify the normative drive towards asset ownership as the mechanism for sustainable economic development.

References

14