Depictions of Mental Illness in Print Media: A Prospective National Sample

John Coverdale, Raymond Nairn, Donna Claasen

Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry · 2002 · 230 citations · 16 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study aimed to prospectively collect and analyze a near‑complete New Zealand print‑media sample depicting mental illness, filling a gap in national‑level reporting. A commercial clipping bureau gathered all mental‑health–related items over four weeks, which were then coded for positive or negative depictions and the manner of representation. Among 600 items, negative portrayals dominated—61 % highlighted dangerousness and 47 % criminality—while only 27 % were positive, and 47 % used generic terminology, underscoring the persistence of stigmatizing stereotypes.

Abstract

Because there are no published reports of depictions of mental illness in print media based on national samples, we set out to prospectively collect and analyse a near complete New Zealand sample of print media.A commercial clipping bureau was contracted to provide cuttings of all items with any mental health or illness aspect over a four week period. These items were analysed for potentially positive and negative depictions and how mental illness was represented within each item. An independent search for additional newspaper items concerning one prominently featured topic indicated that the rate of identification of relevant stories was at least 91%.The collection consisted of six hundred print items which were most commonly news or editorial pieces (n = 562, 93.7%). Negative depictions predominated, with dangerousness to others (n = 368, 61.3%) and criminality (n = 284, 47.3%) being the most common. Positive depictions, including human rights themes, leadership and educational accomplishments occurred in 27% (n = 164) of all items. Generic mental illness terminology without reference to specific diagnostic categories was present in 47% of all items (n = 284).Negative depictions that predominate confirm the stereotypic understanding of mental illness that is stigmatizing. These findings underscore the challenge facing us as mental health professionals attempting to change attitudes towards mental disorders when the stereotypes are so regularly reinforced.

References

16