Carrying the World With the Grace of a Lady and the Grit of a Warrior

Jasmine A. Abrams, Morgan Maxwell, Michell Pope, Faye Z. Belgrave

Psychology of Women Quarterly · 2014 · 286 citations · 54 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Researchers have attempted to unify diverse constructs of Black womanhood, such as the Superwoman Schema and Sisterella Complex, into a single framework that reflects Black women’s roles and intersectional oppression. This study aims to consolidate these overlapping attributes into one term and further delineate the defining characteristics of the Strong Black Woman (SBW) Schema. Through thematic analysis of eight focus groups comprising 44 Black women across age, religion, and education, the authors iteratively coded and compared emerging themes. The SBW Schema emerged as embodying multiple strengths, self‑ethnic pride amid oppression, an inclusive identity, and religious grounding, with these traits linked to mental and physical health outcomes such as distress, depression, obesity, and cardiovascular risk.

Abstract

Across varied disciplines, attempts have been made to capture the multidimensionality of Black womanhood under a unifying framework illustrative of Black women’s perceived roles, responsibilities, and experiences of intersectional oppression. The result has been the emergence of a number of divergent but overlapping constructs (e.g., Superwoman Schema, Sojourner Truth Syndrome, Sisterella Complex, and Strong Black Woman [SBW] Schema). The goal of our study is to integrate overlapping attributes of existing constructs beneath a single term while also expounding upon the defining characteristics of the SBW Schema. Thematic analyses were conducted with data gathered from eight focus groups with 44 Black women from the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States. Women ranged in age from 18 to 91 and were diverse in religious and educational backgrounds. Data analysis involved iterative processes (i.e., continuous development of new codes and constant comparison of themes). Prominent themes identified as characteristics of the SBW Schema were (a) Embodies and Displays Multiple Forms of Strength, (b) Possesses Self/Ethnic Pride in Spite of Intersectional Oppression, (c) Embraces Being Every Woman, and (d) Anchored by Religion/Spirituality. Mental and physical health outcomes (e.g., psychological distress, depressive symptomology, obesity, and cardiovascular disease risk) associated with characteristics of the SBW Schema underscore the importance of the construct and its exploration.

References

54