Journal of Clinical Oncology · 2005 · 36 citations · 28 references
MedicineHealth PromotionPreventive MedicineCancer ScreeningCost-effectiveness AnalysisHealth Services ResearchColorectal CancerCost-effectiveness ComparisonEconomic EvaluationHealthcare Cost AnalysisIncremental Cost-effectiveness AnalysisMedical Technology AssessmentColorectal Cancer PreventionColorectal Cancer ScreeningColorectal Cancer Screening EducationComparative Cost-effectivenessCost-effectivenessCost-effectiveness Of Cancer ControlCost-effectiveness Of Diagnostic TestingFeedback From Reports
PURPOSE: Colorectal cancer screening is underused, particularly in the Veterans Affairs (VA) population. In a randomized controlled trial, a health care provider-directed intervention that offered quarterly feedback to physicians on their patients' colorectal cancer screening rates led to a 9% increase in colorectal cancer screening rates among veterans. The objective of this secondary analysis was to assess the cost effectiveness of the colorectal cancer screening promotion intervention. METHODS: Providers in the intervention arm attended an educational workshop on colorectal cancer screening and received confidential feedback on individual and group-specific colorectal cancer screening rates. The primary end point was completion of colorectal cancer screening tests. Sensitivity analyses investigated cost-effectiveness estimates varying the data collection methods, costs of labor and technology, and the effectiveness of the intervention. RESULTS: Rates of colorectal cancer screening for the intervention versus control arms were 41.3% v 32.4%, respectively (P < .05). The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio was dollar 978 per additional veteran screened based on feedback reports generated from manual review of records. However, if feedback reports could be generated from information technology systems, sensitivity analyses indicate that the cost-effectiveness estimate would decrease to dollar 196 per additional veteran screened. CONCLUSION: An intervention based on quarterly feedback reports to physicians improved colorectal cancer screening rates at a VA medical center. This intervention would be cost effective if relevant data could be generated by existing information technology systems. Our findings may have broad applicability because a 2005 Medicare initiative will provide the VA electronic medical record system as a free benefit to all US physicians.
28
Recommendations of the Panel on Cost-Effectiveness in Health and Medicine
Milton C. Weinstein · JAMA · 1996 · 2.5K citations
The Role of Cost-effectiveness Analysis in Health and Medicine
Louise B. Russell · JAMA · 1996 · 1.2K citations
Recommendations for Reporting Cost-effectiveness Analyses
Joanna E. Siegel · JAMA · 1996 · 1.2K citations
Screening for Colorectal Cancer: Recommendation and Rationale
Annals of Internal Medicine · 2002 · 598 citations