Does Indiscriminate Violence Incite Insurgent Attacks?

Jason Lyall

Journal of Conflict Resolution · 2009 · 502 citations · 54 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Existing theories suggest that indiscriminate state violence is counterproductive, generating grievances and driving victims toward rebel arms. The study tests whether Russian artillery fire in Chechnya increases or decreases insurgent attacks by comparing shelled and nonshelled villages. The authors estimate the effect of artillery fire on insurgent attacks by comparing matched pairs of shelled and nonshelled villages in Chechnya from 2000 to 2005. Shelled villages experienced a 24% reduction in insurgent attacks, and typical retaliation triggers such as lethality and destructiveness were not positively associated with attacks.

Abstract

Does a state's use of indiscriminate violence incite insurgent attacks? To date, most existing theories and empirical studies have concluded that such violence is highly counterproductive because it creates new grievances while forcing victims to seek security, if not safety, in rebel arms. This proposition is tested using Russian artillery fire in Chechnya (2000 to 2005) to estimate indiscriminate violence's effect on subsequent patterns of insurgent attacks across matched pairs of similar shelled and nonshelled villages. The findings are counterintuitive. Shelled villages experience a 24 percent reduction in posttreatment mean insurgent attacks relative to control villages. In addition, commonly cited “triggers” for insurgent retaliation, including the lethality and destructiveness of indiscriminate violence, are either negatively correlated with insurgent attacks or statistically insignificant.

References

54