Organizing Immigrant Communities in American Cities: Is this Transnationalism, or What?

Gustavo Cano

eScholarship (California Digital Library) · 2004 · 15 citations · 14 references

Full text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Following, this paper presents a theoretical section ("On Transnationalism," and "Political Transnationalism and rale Politics!"), then it addresses transnational politics in Chicago and Houston, first, by pointing out the issues, and actors that are involved in transnational activities, and then by addressing the main components of the process itself. On TransnationalismThe term "transnationalism" is now commonly used by a growing cluster of social scientists.However, some authors state that the term is practically useless: it tries to explain too much, and it ends up explaining nothing, or even worst, its regular users seem not to agree on the definition of the term.Portes, Guarnizo, and Landolt (1999), assert that transnational migration studies form a "highly fragmented field that lacks a well-defined theoretical framework."Ebaugh and Saltzman Chafetz (2002) assert that the concept "is a blurry one, a catchall notion" that includes references to globalization, diasporas, transnational social fields, transnational communities, transnational social circuits, and binational societies.As such, these authors state that the term has lost much of its analytical power.This confusion seems to have its origins in the "generosity" of the term.It is generous in the sense that it can be used in fields like sociology, economy, political science, history, geography, and anthropology.In essence, the term is a multidisciplinary, complex one.This makes things relatively easy for the lightly-informed critics of the concept.Transnationalism, as a whole, will always lack something; there will always be something that is left out of its explanatory frame.No wonder.The term itself is developed through several disciplines in a simultaneous way.Different theoretical interpretations lead to the application of different methodologies and different considerations of units of analysis, which go from the individual, the family, organizations, the society, the economy and cultural practices, to the interactive foreign policies between two or more nation-states.However, there are some common agreements on the nature and essence of the term.It

References

14