Genetics · 2010 · 842 citations · 41 references
Life SciencesBiostatisticsGeneticsGenomicsQuantitative GeneticsStatistical GeneticsGenetic ArchitectureGenetic EvaluationGenomic PredictionQuantitative Trait LociQuantitative Trait Loci MappingQuantitative Trait Locus MappingGenetic Merit AssessmentGenetic Parameter EstimationGenetic Parameters EstimationGenomic Prediction Of Complex TraitsHeritability Of Complex TraitsHeritability Of Quantitative TraitsSingle-nucleotide Polymorphism AnalysisStatistical Genomic Prediction Models
Genome‑wide evaluation methods are increasingly used to predict genetic merit from high‑throughput SNP data, yet uncertainty remains about which method is most appropriate for complex traits. The study tests whether different genome‑wide evaluation methods respond differently to the genetic architecture of quantitative traits. The authors compared GBLUP and BayesB via stochastic simulation across varying population sizes and QTL numbers, and extended deterministic equations to predict method accuracy and estimate Me and NQTL. GBLUP maintained constant accuracy across QTL numbers, whereas BayesB outperformed GBLUP when QTL were few but fell behind as QTL increased; predictions of accuracy and estimates of Me and NQTL matched simulations, indicating that relative method accuracy depends on Me and trait architecture.
Abstract The rapid increase in high-throughput single-nucleotide polymorphism data has led to a great interest in applying genome-wide evaluation methods to identify an individual's genetic merit. Genome-wide evaluation combines statistical methods with genomic data to predict genetic values for complex traits. Considerable uncertainty currently exists in determining which genome-wide evaluation method is the most appropriate. We hypothesize that genome-wide methods deal differently with the genetic architecture of quantitative traits and genomes. A genomic linear method (GBLUP), and a genomic nonlinear Bayesian variable selection method (BayesB) are compared using stochastic simulation across three effective population sizes and a wide range of numbers of quantitative trait loci (NQTL). GBLUP had a constant accuracy, for a given heritability and sample size, regardless of NQTL. BayesB had a higher accuracy than GBLUP when NQTL was low, but this advantage diminished as NQTL increased and when NQTL became large, GBLUP slightly outperformed BayesB. In addition, deterministic equations are extended to predict the accuracy of both methods and to estimate the number of independent chromosome segments (Me) and NQTL. The predictions of accuracy and estimates of Me and NQTL were generally in good agreement with results from simulated data. We conclude that the relative accuracy of GBLUP and BayesB for a given number of records and heritability are highly dependent on Me, which is a property of the target genome, as well as the architecture of the trait (NQTL).
41
Introduction to Quantitative Genetics.
A. W. F. Edwards, D. S. Falconer · Biometrics · 1982 · 21.8K citations
Life Sciences, Biology, Genetics +12
Efficient Methods to Compute Genomic Predictions
P.M. VanRaden · Journal of Dairy Science · 2008 · 6.3K citations · Full text
The Structure of Haplotype Blocks in the Human Genome
Stacey Gabriel, S. F. Schaffner, Huy Nguyen et al. · Science · 2002 · 5.9K citations