Chinese Relationalism: Theoretical Construction and Methodological Considerations

Kwang‐Kuo Hwang

Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour · 2000 · 321 citations · 15 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Confucian ethics for ordinary people manifest in lifeworlds produce a phenomenology of persons‑in‑relations, as shown by Fei’s differential order and Hsu’s psychosociogram. The article aims to establish Chinese relationalism as a research tradition grounded in constructive realism, applying it to models to study Chinese social behavior. The authors reinterpret Ho’s person‑in‑relations concepts and employ three theoretical models—Face and Favor, Confucian ethics for ordinary people, and a conflict resolution model—as microworlds to illustrate person‑in‑relations within Chinese culture using constructive realism.

Abstract

The goal of this article is attempting to establish a research tradition of Chinese relationalism on the methodological grounds of constructive realism. Two of Ho’s (1993, 1998a) key concepts, person‐in‐relations and persons‐in‐relation, are carefully examined and reinterpreted. Three of my theoretical models, namely, my Face and Favor model (Hwang, 1987), Confucian ethics for ordinary people (Hwang, 1995), and a conflict resolution model (Hwang, 1997‐8), are conceived of as microworlds for illustrating an account of person‐in relations in Chinese culture. The manifestation of Confucian ethics for ordinary people in one’s lifeworld results in the phenomenology of persons‐in‐relations as depicted by Fei’s (1948) differential order or Hsu’s (1971a) psychosociogram. Applying constructive realism to my models and using the result as a framework for studying Chinese social behavior constitutes Chinese relationalism.

References

15