MADS-box genes reveal that gnetophytes are more closely related to conifers than to flowering plants

Kai‐Uwe Winter, Annette Becker, Thomas Münster, Jan T. Kim, Heinz Saedler

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · 1999 · 314 citations · 40 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The evolutionary origin of angiosperms remains enigmatic, with morphological studies favoring a sister relationship to gnetophytes but molecular analyses failing to support the anthophyte clade and offering weak or controversial alternative groupings. The study seeks to clarify angiosperm origins by determining their sister group among extant taxa. The authors isolated 13 MADS‑type floral homeotic gene homologs from the gnetophyte Gnetum gnemon to investigate their phylogenetic relationships. Phylogenetic analysis shows that Gnetum genes cluster with conifers, not angiosperms, providing strong evidence that gnetophytes are sister to conifers and that flower‑like reproductive structures evolved independently in the two lineages.

Abstract

The evolutionary origin of the angiosperms (flowering plants sensu stricto ) is still enigmatic. Answers to the question of angiosperm origins are intimately connected to the identification of their sister group among extinct and extant taxa. Most phylogenetic analyses based on morphological data agree that among the groups of extant seed plants, the gnetophytes are the sister group of the angiosperms. According to this view, angiosperms and gnetophytes are the only extant members of a clade called “anthophytes” to emphasize their shared possession of flower-like reproductive structures. However, most phylogeny reconstructions based on molecular data so far did not support an anthophyte clade, but also could not clarify the case because support for alternative groupings has been weak or controversial. We have isolated 13 different homologs of MADS-type floral homeotic genes from the gnetophyte Gnetum gnemon . Five of these genes fall into monophyletic gene clades also comprising putatively orthologous genes from flowering plants and conifers, among them orthologs of floral homeotic B and C function genes. Within these clades the Gnetum genes always form distinct subclades together with the respective conifer genes, to the exclusion of the angiosperm genes. This provides strong molecular evidence for a sister-group relationship between gnetophytes and conifers, which is in contradiction to widely accepted interpretations of morphological data for almost a century. Our phylogeny reconstructions and the outcome of expression studies suggest that complex features such as flower-like reproductive structures and double-fertilization arose independently in gnetophytes and angiosperms.

References

40