Rethinking History · 2007 · 27 citations · 32 references
Social SciencesCommunicationFilm StudiesMedia CriticismMedia StudiesMedia TheoryMedia RepresentationModernityRepresentation In FilmAesthetic PoliticsDiscourses Of RepresentationMass Culture CriticismMass Culture CritiqueMass Media HistoryPolitical AestheticsProsthetic EmbodimentRemembrance Ceremonies
Abstract While Alison Landsberg's argument for a politically progressive prosthetic memory made possible by modern media and global capital is theoretically provocative and politically appealing, it is ultimately unsustainable. What she describes as memory might better be called a combination of knowledge and empathy. And her account of the prosthetic quality of movies and experiential museums is equally applicable to more traditional verbal texts and, indeed, to symbol use per se. Nevertheless, Landsberg's book (Prosthetic Memory: The Transformation of American Remembrance in the Age of Mass Culture, Columbia University Press, 2004) presents a valuable new way of thinking about the problem of representing and responding to events one did not experience. Keywords: EmpathyHistoryMediaMemoryNarrativePolitics Notes [1] Theories of postmodernism in the 1980s coming from literary and philosophical traditions (and in the 1960s and 70s from critics of art and architecture) defended the products and ethos of popular culture. (See, for instance, Foster 1983 Foster H. The Anti-Aesthetic: Essays on Postmodern Culture Bay Press Port Townsend, WA 1983 [Google Scholar]; Ross 1988 Ross A. Universal Abandon: The Politics of Postmodernism University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis, MN 1988 [Google Scholar]; McRobbie 1989 McRobbie A. Zoot Suits and Second Hand Dresses: An Anthology of Fashion and Music Routledge New York and London 1989 [Crossref] , [Google Scholar] and Modleski 1986 Modleski T. Studies in Entertainment: Critical Approaches to Mass Culture Indiana University Press Bloomington, IN 1986 Indianapolis, IN [Google Scholar]—this last containing the exemplarily titled essay 'Theodor Adorno Meets the Cadillacs' (Gendron 1986 Gendron, B. 1986. "'Theodor Adorno meets the Cadillacs'". In Studies in Entertainment: Critical Approaches to Mass Culture, Edited by: Modleski, T. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press. Indianapolis, IN [Google Scholar])). Regarding visual art and architecture, see Venturi et al. (1977 Venturi, R., Izenour, S. and Brown, D. S. 1977. Learning From Las Vegas—Revised Edition: The Forgotten Symbolism of Architectural Form, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. [Google Scholar]) and Wallis (1994). This direction of thought, which seeks also to blur the boundary between popular (or mass) culture and the culture of 'high' art and theory, is now an important part of scholarship on modernism. (Cf. North 1994 North, M. 1994. The Dialect of Modernism: Race, Language, and Twentieth-Century Literature, Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar], 1999 North, M. 1999. Reading 1922: A Return to the Scene of the Modern, Oxford: Oxford University Press. [Google Scholar]; Weiss 1994 Weiss, J. 1994. The Popular Culture of Modern Art: Picasso, Duchamp, and Avant-Gardism, New Haven, CN: Yale University Press. [Google Scholar]; Armstrong 2005 Armstrong, T. 2005. Modernism: A Cultural History, Cambridge and Malden, MA: Polity Press. [Google Scholar]; Mao & Walkowitz 2006 Mao D Walkowitz R. L. Bad Modernisms Duke University Press Durham, NC 2006 London [Crossref] , [Google Scholar].) [2] Summarizing his view of the relation between consciousness, symbolization, and memory, Edelman writes, 'primary consciousness is limited to the remembered present. It is necessary for the emergence of higher-order consciousness, and it continues to operate in animals capable of higher-order consciousness. Higher-order consciousness arises with the evolutionary onset of semantic capabilities, and it flowers with the accession of language and symbolic reference. Linguistic capabilities require a new kind of memory . … The speech areas mediating categorization and memory for language interact with already evolved conceptual areas of the brain' (pp. 149 – 50). [3] Mirror neurons, write Giocomo Rizzolatti and Michael Arbib, 'represent a system that matches observed events to similar, internally generated actions, and in this way forms a link between the observer and the actor.' They thus provide 'a necessary bridge from "doing" to "communicating," as the link between actor and observer becomes a link between the sender and the receiver of each message' (1998, p. 188). See also Iacoboni et al. (2005 Iacoboni, M., Molnar-Szakacs, I., Gallese, V., Buccino, G., Mazziotta, J. C. and Rizzolatti, G. 2005. 'Grasping the intentions of others with one's own mirror neuron system'. PloS Biology, 3(3) Available at: http://biology.PloSjournals.org[Crossref], [PubMed] , [Google Scholar]). [4] See also recent clinical, philosophical, and literary research on 'theory of mind,' a term denoting the nearly universal human ability to recognize that others possess minds like one's own and therefore will be likely to respond to similar events or circumstances in roughly similar ways. (Cf. Baron-Cohen 1995 Baron-Cohen, S. 1995. Mindblindness: An Essay on Autism and Theory of Mind, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]; Baron-Cohen et al. 2000 Baron-Cohen S. Tager-Flusberg H. Cohen D. J. Understanding Other Minds: Perspectives From Developmental Cognitive Neuroscience Oxford University Press Oxford and New York 2000 [Google Scholar]; Zunshine 2006 Zunshine, L. 2006. Why We Read Fiction: Theory of Mind and the Novel, Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press. [Google Scholar]). [5] The principal objection that can be raised against the Holocaust Museum, I think, is its presence in the nation's capital juxtaposed with the absence there of a museum dedicated to the history of American race relations and the crime and catastrophe of slavery. Landsberg addresses this issue by referring to African American students' visits to the museum and to the museum's power to 'teach ethical thinking, generate empathy, and thereby reconfigure a person's worldview' (2004, p. 138). These are important points, yet the fact remains that Washington, DC contains a major museum dedicated to what is a Jewish and European event and does not have a museum reminding and educating visitors and residents about slavery. Slavery is a central event in American history; the Holocaust is not. It is therefore odd that the nation's capital has a museum for the latter and not the former. This seems to me a significant instance of ideological evasion, amnesia, or denial. [6] See the work of Robert McChesney (2000 McChesney, R. W. 2000. Rich Media, Poor Democracy: Communication Politics in Dubious Times, New York: New Press. [Google Scholar], 2004 McChesney, R. W. 2004. The Problem of the Media: US Communication Politics in the 21st Century, New York: Monthly Review Press. [Google Scholar]) for a thorough account of the history and consequences of corporate media consolidation in the USA. The existence and dominance of a corporate media governed by market imperatives—and the accompanying commodification of information—McChesney argues, has severely damaged American public discourse and democratic processes. Robert Kuttner (1997 Kuttner, R. 1997. Everything For Sale: The Virtues and Limits of Markets, New York: Knopf. [Google Scholar]) likewise argues that if Americans are to reconstruct a democratic polity, this task must be accomplished in a realm other than that of consumption. It is true that McChesney and Kuttner, whose broader arguments are historical and structural, do not acknowledge the sorts of cultural products at the center of Landsberg's discussion. They would, I think, have to acknowledge the value of particular media products, but would still maintain that the trajectory of corporate domination of media has resulted in a narrowing of opportunities for democratic expression. For a more technical critique of the neoliberal ideology in which market freedoms supplant political ones, see David Harvey (2005 Harvey, D. 2005. A Brief History of Neoliberalism, Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]). McChesney, Kuttner, and Harvey all, I think, would argue that Landsberg ignores the systemic bases and consequences of the commodifications of history and memory she discusses. [7] Kerwin Lee Klein (2000 Klein, K. L. 2000. 'On the emergence of memory in historical discourse'. Representations, Winter: 127–150. [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar]) describes how contemporary discourses of historical memory tend to invoke theological categories. Memory, he writes, 'projects an immediacy that we feel has been lost from history' (p. 129) and that 'fairly vibrates with the fullness of Being' (p. 130). Klein also points out ways in which these 'archaic forms' (p. 132) have been taken up by directions of postmodern theory—an observation that would seem to apply to some degree to Landsberg's argument. Dominick LaCapra (2004 LaCapra, D. 2004. History in Transit: Experience, Identity, Critical Theory, Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]) unpacks the notion of 'experience,' of which 'memory is a prominent part (indeed at times a metonym)' (p. 67), as counter-symbolic placeholder: a kind of 'residual concept—what remains … when meaning and language do not exhaust their objects. The notion of experience as undefined residue might be argued to hold a position analogous to that of divinity or the sacred in negative theology' (p. 39). With regard to the textual transmission of trauma, see my After the End (Berger 1999 Berger, J. 1999. After the End: Representations of Post-Apocalypse, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. [Google Scholar]), as well as work by LaCapra (1994 LaCapra, D. 1994. Representing the Holocaust: History, Theory, Trauma, Ithaca: Cornell University Press. [Google Scholar], 2001 LaCapra, D. 2001. Writing History, Writing Trauma, Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press. London [Google Scholar]), Caruth (1996 Caruth, C. 1996. Unclaimed Experience: Trauma, Narrative, and History, Baltimore, MA: Johns Hopkins University Press. [Crossref] , [Google Scholar]), Hirsch (1997 Hirsch, M. 1997. Family Frames: Photography, Narrative, and Postmemory, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. [Google Scholar]), Rothberg (2000 Rothberg, M. 2000. Traumatic Realism: The Demands of Holocaust Representation, Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. London [Google Scholar]), and Mandel (2006 Mandel, N. 2006. Against the Unspeakable: Complicity, the Holocaust, and Slavery in America, Charlottesville, VA: University of Virginia Press. [Google Scholar]). For an insightful critique of much of the scholarship on text and trauma, see Amy Hungerford (2003 Hungerford, A. 2003. The Holocaust of Texts: Genocide, Literature, and Personification, Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. London [Google Scholar]).
32
Between Memory and History: Les Lieux de Mémoire
Pierre Nora · Representations · 1989 · 4.6K citations
Mindblindness: an essay on autism and theory of mind
Choice Reviews Online · 1995 · 3.7K citations
Unclaimed experience: trauma, narrative, and history
Choice Reviews Online · 1997 · 2.7K citations