COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND SIMULATED PHOSPHORUS LOSSES WITH INDEXED SITE VULNERABILITY

Tamie L. Veith, Andrew N. Sharpley, Jennifer L. Weld, William J. Gburek

Transactions of the ASAE · 2005 · 67 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Nonpoint-source losses of agricultural phosphorus (P) at field and watershed scales must be quantified tofacilitate selection and placement of P control measures. Quantification of P loss has been pursued through field monitoring,simulation models, and risk assessment indices. However, the intended users of these methods differ, impacting each methodsfunctional design and ease-of-use. For example, the Pennsylvania P Index, a risk assessment tool for planners, requires lessdiscipline-specific knowledge and more readily available data than the Soil and Water Assessment Tool (SWAT), a complex,watershed-level, research-based simulation model. This study compared measured losses of P from the outlet of a 39.5 hamixed land use watershed (FD-36) in south-central Pennsylvania with watershed-level losses predicted by SWAT. Measuredwatershed exports of dissolved P (0.06 kg ha-1) and total P (0.24 kg ha-1) during the 7-month sampling period were similarin magnitude to SWAT-predicted losses (0.05 and 0.73 kg ha-1, respectively). Additionally, the study compared field-level Plosses predicted by SWAT with field-level vulnerabilities to P loss derived by the P Index. The P Index and SWAT categorized73% of the 22 fields similarly in terms of vulnerability to P loss, with Pearson correlation significant at p = 0.07; all exceptone of the remaining six fields were over- or underpredicted by a single risk category. Results indicate that while actual Ploss from FD-36 was small, three fields contributed a major proportion of this loss. Additionally, this study suggests that theP Index can provide land managers with a reliable assessment of where P loss occurs within a watershed, thus allowing moreeffective placement and selection of conservation practices, which lead toward improved downstream water quality.