Melodramas of Beset Black Manhood? Meditations on African-American Masculinity as Scholarly Topos and Social Menace: An Introduction

Stephanie J. Brown, Keith Clark

Callaloo · 2003 · 17 citations · 3 references

Concepts

Abstract

Given its preeminence in American and African-American literary history, one might think of Ellison's magnum opus as the "Bible" of contemporary African-American writing, functioning as the genesis of postmodern black writing much as Hemingway apotheosized Huckleberry Finn as the grounding narrative for the modern American novel. 1 Certainly, the novel's opening five words, their syntactically discrepant assertion of agency and absence, capture the dominant cultural episteme with respect to the bases of black ontology: the paradox of both being and (not) being black. The first-person subject pronoun "I," whose referent is "invisible," reifies absence; the oxymoronic and incongruous "invisible man" hearkens back to Frederick Douglass' similarly self assertive and self-erasive characterization of himself as an [End Page 732] "American Slave" in the title of the great patri-narrative of African-American men's literary genealogy. As the Invisible Man's fictive descendant, Gaines's Grant Wiggins, the schoolteacher protagonist in his 1993 novel A Lesson Before Dying, declares a corresponding absent presence during the murder trial of a semi-literate young black male whom the state will subsequently execute for a crime he did not commit. Grant's chimerical sense of self is occasioned by the trial itself: his utterance bespeaks a cultural narrative that collapses distinctions between education and ignorance, freedom and imprisonment, guilt and innocence. These fictive testaments to black male social and corporeal annihilation make Ishmael Reed's effusively over-the-top declaration that "[b]eing a black man in America is like being a spectator at your own lynching" (16) more than mere rhetorical jujitsu. African-American literature about men has chronicled blackness in the white American imaginary, where metaphorical and occasional physical "lynchings"—notwithstanding Clarence Thomas's self-serving invocation of the term—are part and parcel of black men's social, discursive, and physical reality.

References

3