Interlaboratory comparison of a method to evaluate the effects of chemicals on fish growth

M. J. Mallett, N. J. Grandy, R F Lacey

Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry · 1997 · 14 citations · 4 references

Concepts

Abstract

Abstract A protocol for the evaluation of chemicals on the growth rate of juvenile rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss Walbaum) over a 28-day period has been evaluated by comparison of the test results obtained by 15 laboratories from seven countries in the European Union. Two test substances were used, 3,4-dichloroaniline (DCA) and linear alkylbenzene sulfonate (LAS). Fourteen test results were received for DCA and seven for LAS. The data were analyzed in two ways: the evaluation of the lowest observed effect concentrations (LOECs), and regression analysis to estimate the concentration of the substance causing a 25% reduction in growth relative to the controls (EC25). The latter method clearly provided a number of advantages over estimation of LOECs. These included less dependence of the result upon the spacing between exposure concentrations and upon the arbitrary choice of level of statistical significance. In addition it was possible to estimate an EC25 for more data sets than was possible for LOEC estimation. The sensitivity of the test was comparable with other chronic tests (Daphnia juvenile production and fathead minnow early life stage tests) for DCA and LAS. For DCA the overall mean EC25 was 223 μg/L the EC25s found by individual laboratories ranged from 100 to 390 μg/L. For LAS the EC25 ranged from 1,220 to 2,810 μg/L.

References

4