Démocratie et monarchie chez Plutarque

Etienne Teixeira

Dialogues d histoire ancienne · 1995 · 31 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

After having mentionned the main meanings enclosed in the word "politeia", Plutarch tells us what he thinks about the principal kinds of governments that are monarchy, oligarchy and democracy, insisting specialy on monarchy and democracy. He hastens to exclude tyrannical government that, according to him, gives birth only to terror and involves anarchy. The kind of government that seems to him to be perhaps not the best, but at any rate the most conformable to justice and interest for all people is monarchy, for it is able to free human being from constraint and to give him some assurance. Democracy, as for it, from what liberty and harmony have to be inseparable, and that supposes equality must take care of keeping general interest. So, democracy looks like monarchy even so little. However, Plutarch's realism is obvious when the author sees clearly that it is necessary to make some true efforts in order to get to real monarchy. On the other hand, even if a sovereign knows what he has to do, he must use gentle means, lest his fellow-citizens should undergo fear almost steadily.