Determination of nutrient uptake kinetic parameters: a comparison of methods

Abstract

Three methods which have been used to determine nutrient uptake hnetic parameters were compared using steady-state NH,-limited cultures of the chrysophyte Pseudopedinella pyriforrnis. The first 2 methods involved a multiple flask incubation where different concentrations of substrate were added to each flask. Method 1 used a variable incubation time, while the incubation time of Method 2 was short and constant. The third method, the perturbation method, involved one large addition of the substrate to one culture and hence the nutritional past history varied throughout the experiment. This method was used also with the diatoms Skeletonema costatum and Chaetoceros debilis in Si-Limited chemostats. Results inhcate that, for nutrient-limited cultures, kinetic parameters are best estimated using multiple additions of the substrate and a short constant incubation time (Method 2). It appears that this method determines membrane transport, which is still not completely free of feedback inhibition even when the incubation time is very short (e.g. 2 min). The short incubation time is necessary because the maximal uptake velocity (V,) decreases with increasing incubation time especially for phosphate and ammonium. Method 3 provides valuable information on a third parameter, V,, the approximate assimilation rate of the limiting nutrient, that is not obtained by the other methods. Multlple sequential additions of the limiting nutrient to N-or Si-limited Skeletonema costaturn and Chaetoceros debilis revealed that if the additions were small (e.g. 2 pM NH,), there was no change in subsequently determined nutrient uptake kinetic parameters. If the sequential additions were larger (e.g. 6 PM) then the maximal uptake rate slowed with time.